Fiscal Framework Review - Amendment 2
Submitted by:
Alex Cole-Hamilton
Date lodged:
Tuesday, 05 December 2023
Motion reference: S6M-11546.2
Current status: Taken in the Chamber on Wednesday, 06 December 2023
As an amendment to motion S6M-11546 in the name of Shona Robison (Fiscal Framework Review), leave out from first "limited" to end and insert "improvements to the Scottish Fiscal Framework, following a joint review with the UK Government, and welcomes the outcome, which will protect and enhance devolved powers, providing more flexibility and choice than ever before, continuing to build on the cross-party agreement reached at the Smith Commission in 2014, but condemns the Scottish Government’s repeated failure to treat local authorities fairly in setting the Scottish Budget or to establish a new fiscal framework that ensures that local authorities get a fair share of resources, harming their efforts to reduce poverty, grow local economies, tackle the climate emergency and invest in essential public services, including schools."
Vote
Result
56 for, 64 against, 0 abstained, 9 did not vote
Vote Defeated
Scottish National Party
0 for
56 against
0 abstained
7 did not vote
+ Show details
+ Hide details
For
0
Against
Gougeon, Mairi
McLennan, Paul
Doris, Bob
Don-Innes, Natalie
Ewing, Fergus
MacGregor, Fulton
Stevenson, Collette
Stewart, Kevin
Adam, Karen
Arthur, Tom
Swinney, John
MacDonald, Gordon
Thomson, Michelle
Fairlie, Jim
Sturgeon, Nicola
McKelvie, Christina
Hepburn, Jamie
McNair, Marie
FitzPatrick, Joe
Stewart, Kaukab
Mackay, Rona
Dey, Graeme
Allan, Dr Alasdair
Minto, Jenni
Maguire, Ruth
Callaghan, Stephanie
Gilruth, Jenny
McKee, Ivan
Nicoll, Audrey
Brown, Siobhian
Forbes, Kate
Dornan, James
Robertson, Angus
Gibson, Kenneth
Kidd, Bill
Mason, John
Dunbar, Jackie
Constance, Angela
Macpherson, Ben
Somerville, Shirley-Anne
Matheson, Michael
Todd, Maree
Beattie, Colin
Harper, Emma
Brown, Keith
Hyslop, Fiona
Robison, Shona
Ewing, Annabelle
Tweed, Evelyn
Adam, George
Whitham, Elena
Coffey, Willie
McMillan, Stuart
Adamson, Clare
Haughey, Clare
Gray, Neil
Abstained
0
Did not vote
Martin, Gillian
McAllan, Màiri
Torrance, David
Yousaf, Humza
Grahame, Christine
Lochhead, Richard
Roddick, Emma
Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party
31 for
0 against
0 abstained
0 did not vote
+ Show details
+ Hide details
For
Webber, Sue
Burnett, Alexander
Hamilton, Rachael
Dowey, Sharon
Gulhane, Sandesh
Stewart, Alexander
Carlaw, Jackson
Smith, Liz
Gallacher, Meghan
Greene, Jamie
Hoy, Craig
White, Tess
Kerr, Stephen
Simpson, Graham
Lumsden, Douglas
Mountain, Edward
Ross, Douglas
McCall, Roz
Whittle, Brian
Balfour, Jeremy
Fraser, Murdo
Golden, Maurice
Gosal, Pam
Findlay, Russell
Carson, Finlay
Cameron, Donald
Halcro Johnston, Jamie
Mundell, Oliver
Kerr, Liam
Briggs, Miles
Wells, Annie
Against
0
Abstained
0
Did not vote
0
Scottish Labour
22 for
0 against
0 abstained
0 did not vote
+ Show details
+ Hide details
For
Bibby, Neil
Sarwar, Anas
McNeill, Pauline
Baker, Claire
Marra, Michael
Sweeney, Paul
Baillie, Jackie
Leonard, Richard
Johnson, Daniel
Mochan, Carol
Clark, Katy
Grant, Rhoda
Whitfield, Martin
Duncan-Glancy, Pam
Rowley, Alex
Smyth, Colin
Lennon, Monica
O'Kane, Paul
Villalba, Mercedes
Boyack, Sarah
Choudhury, Foysol
Griffin, Mark
Against
0
Abstained
0
Did not vote
0
Scottish Green Party
0 for
7 against
0 abstained
0 did not vote
+ Show details
+ Hide details
For
0
Against
Chapman, Maggie
Ruskell, Mark
Greer, Ross
Mackay, Gillian
Harvie, Patrick
Burgess, Ariane
Slater, Lorna
Abstained
0
Did not vote
0
Scottish Liberal Democrats
3 for
0 against
0 abstained
1 did not vote
+ Show details
+ Hide details
For
Rennie, Willie
Cole-Hamilton, Alex
Wishart, Beatrice
Against
0
Abstained
0
Did not vote
Alba Party
0 for
1 against
0 abstained
0 did not vote
+ Show details
+ Hide details
For
0
Against
Abstained
0
Did not vote
0
No Party Affiliation
0 for
0 against
0 abstained
1 did not vote
+ Show details
+ Hide details
For
0
Against
0
Abstained
0
Did not vote
Related motion
Motion ref. S6M-11546
Submitted by: Shona Robison, Dundee City East, Scottish National Party, Date lodged: Monday, December 4, 2023
Supported by: George Adam, Tom Arthur, Joe FitzPatrick
Result
63 for, 56 against, 1 abstained, 9 did not vote
Vote Passed
Defeated related amendments
Motion ref. S6M-11546.1
Submitted by: Ash Regan, Edinburgh Eastern, Alba Party, Date lodged: Tuesday, December 5, 2023
Current status: Taken in the chamber on Wednesday, December 6, 2023
Result
1 for, 119 against, 0 abstained, 9 did not vote
Vote Defeated
Motion ref. S6M-11546.3
Submitted by: Michael Marra, North East Scotland, Scottish Labour, Date lodged: Tuesday, December 5, 2023
Current status: Taken in the chamber on Wednesday, December 6, 2023
Result
25 for, 95 against, 0 abstained, 9 did not vote
Vote Defeated
Motion ref. S6M-11546.4
Submitted by: Liz Smith, Mid Scotland and Fife, Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party, Date lodged: Tuesday, December 5, 2023
Current status: Taken in the chamber on Wednesday, December 6, 2023
Result
31 for, 89 against, 0 abstained, 9 did not vote
Vote Defeated