Fiscal Framework Review - Amendment 1
Submitted by:
Ash Regan
Date lodged:
Tuesday, 05 December 2023
Motion reference: S6M-11546.1
Current status: Taken in the Chamber on Wednesday, 06 December 2023
As an amendment to motion S6M-11546 in the name of Shona Robison (Fiscal Framework Review), leave out from "believes" to end and insert "notes that although VAT assignment was recommended by the Smith Commission, several years later, half of VAT raised in Scotland that was to be assigned to the Scottish Budget is still not included in the updated fiscal framework, and believes that only with the full powers of independence will the Scottish Parliament have all the fiscal levers required to reduce poverty, grow the economy, tackle climate change by investing in the future of carbon capture technology in the North Sea, and invest in public services."
Vote
Result
1 for, 119 against, 0 abstained, 9 did not vote
Vote Defeated
Scottish National Party
0 for
56 against
0 abstained
7 did not vote
+ Show details
+ Hide details
For
0
Against
Ewing, Annabelle Robison, Shona Mason, John Somerville, Shirley-Anne Brown, Siobhian FitzPatrick, Joe Kidd, Bill Thomson, Michelle Forbes, Kate Maguire, Ruth Don-Innes, Natalie McMillan, Stuart Dey, Graeme Hepburn, Jamie Dornan, James McKelvie, Christina Whitham, Elena McNair, Marie Gray, Neil Robertson, Angus Brown, Keith McKee, Ivan MacGregor, Fulton Matheson, Michael Nicoll, Audrey Gougeon, Mairi Haughey, Clare Allan, Dr Alasdair Stevenson, Collette Macpherson, Ben Dunbar, Jackie Tweed, Evelyn Gibson, Kenneth McLennan, Paul Coffey, Willie MacDonald, Gordon Harper, Emma Adamson, Clare Ewing, Fergus Adam, George Sturgeon, Nicola Arthur, Tom Gilruth, Jenny Callaghan, Stephanie Hyslop, Fiona Doris, Bob Minto, Jenni Beattie, Colin Adam, Karen Stewart, Kaukab Swinney, John Constance, Angela Mackay, Rona Todd, Maree Fairlie, Jim Stewart, Kevin
Abstained
0
Did not vote
Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party
0 for
31 against
0 abstained
0 did not vote
+ Show details
+ Hide details
For
0
Against
Ross, Douglas McCall, Roz Smith, Liz Simpson, Graham Carlaw, Jackson Webber, Sue Fraser, Murdo Burnett, Alexander Gosal, Pam Gallacher, Meghan Greene, Jamie Kerr, Stephen Mundell, Oliver Golden, Maurice Lumsden, Douglas Carson, Finlay Stewart, Alexander Wells, Annie Mountain, Edward Cameron, Donald Halcro Johnston, Jamie Findlay, Russell Whittle, Brian Hoy, Craig Kerr, Liam Briggs, Miles Gulhane, Sandesh White, Tess Dowey, Sharon Hamilton, Rachael Balfour, Jeremy
Abstained
0
Did not vote
0
Scottish Labour
0 for
22 against
0 abstained
0 did not vote
+ Show details
+ Hide details
For
0
Against
McNeill, Pauline Rowley, Alex Sarwar, Anas O'Kane, Paul Choudhury, Foysol Duncan-Glancy, Pam Whitfield, Martin Mochan, Carol Johnson, Daniel Baker, Claire Sweeney, Paul Boyack, Sarah Clark, Katy Smyth, Colin Bibby, Neil Leonard, Richard Villalba, Mercedes Lennon, Monica Marra, Michael Grant, Rhoda Baillie, Jackie Griffin, Mark
Abstained
0
Did not vote
0
Scottish Green Party
0 for
7 against
0 abstained
0 did not vote
+ Show details
+ Hide details
For
0
Against
Abstained
0
Did not vote
0
Scottish Liberal Democrats
0 for
3 against
0 abstained
1 did not vote
+ Show details
+ Hide details
For
0
Against
Abstained
0
Did not vote
Alba Party
1 for
0 against
0 abstained
0 did not vote
+ Show details
+ Hide details
For
Against
0
Abstained
0
Did not vote
0
No Party Affiliation
0 for
0 against
0 abstained
1 did not vote
+ Show details
+ Hide details
For
0
Against
0
Abstained
0
Did not vote
Related motion
Motion ref. S6M-11546
Submitted by: Shona Robison, Dundee City East, Scottish National Party, Date lodged: Monday, December 4, 2023
Supported by: George Adam, Tom Arthur, Joe FitzPatrick
Result
63 for, 56 against, 1 abstained, 9 did not vote
Vote Passed
Defeated related amendments
Motion ref. S6M-11546.2
Submitted by: Alex Cole-Hamilton, Edinburgh Western, Scottish Liberal Democrats, Date lodged: Tuesday, December 5, 2023
Current status: Taken in the chamber on Wednesday, December 6, 2023
Result
56 for, 64 against, 0 abstained, 9 did not vote
Vote Defeated
Motion ref. S6M-11546.3
Submitted by: Michael Marra, North East Scotland, Scottish Labour, Date lodged: Tuesday, December 5, 2023
Current status: Taken in the chamber on Wednesday, December 6, 2023
Result
25 for, 95 against, 0 abstained, 9 did not vote
Vote Defeated
Motion ref. S6M-11546.4
Submitted by: Liz Smith, Mid Scotland and Fife, Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party, Date lodged: Tuesday, December 5, 2023
Current status: Taken in the chamber on Wednesday, December 6, 2023
Result
31 for, 89 against, 0 abstained, 9 did not vote
Vote Defeated