Questions and answers

Question reference: S5W-27275

Asked by: Jamie Halcro Johnston, MSP for Highlands and Islands, Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party
Date lodged: Tuesday, 04 February 2020
Current Status: Answered by Paul Wheelhouse on 26 February 2020

To ask the Scottish Government how much it has spent on legal action in relation to disputes with (a) Pentland Ferries and (b) David MacBrayne Ltd in each year since 2007-08.

The following table details the legal costs in relation to the disputes with (a) Pentland Ferries Ltd and (b) CalMac Ferries Ltd as at 30 January 2020.

Year	Company	Legal Costs	Total
2018	Pentland Ferries Ltd	£1,750.00
2019	Pentland Ferries Ltd	£58,385.00	£60,135.00
2019	CalMac Ferries Ltd	£2,450.00
2020	CalMac Ferries Ltd	£1,560.00	£4,010.00
			£64,145.00*

*These are net figures exclusive of VAT.

Pentland Ferries Ltd

Scottish Ministers were awarded costs, and we are currently in the process of recovering judicial expenses (i.e. costs) from Pentland Ferries.

CalMac legal proceedings

CalMac raised legal proceedings in the Court of Session on 25 November 2019 against the decision to award the Northern Isles Ferry Services (NIFS) contract to Serco Northlink.

CalMac offered to abandon their case on 31 January 2020, on a no expenses basis, which Scottish Ministers accepted. This means that both parties will bear their own costs.

It should be noted that not all invoices in relation to the dispute with CalMac Ferries Ltd have been received.

Question reference: S5W-27276

Asked by: Jamie Halcro Johnston, MSP for Highlands and Islands, Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party
Date lodged: Tuesday, 04 February 2020
Current Status: Answered by Michael Matheson on 26 February 2020

To ask the Scottish Government whether work to dual the (a) A9 and (b) A96 road is progressing on target.

The Scottish Government intends to dual the A9 between Perth and Inverness by 2025. Construction of the second section to be dualled between Luncarty and Birnam is progressing well and at the same time, design work continues at pace with eight of the remaining nine dualling schemes now subject to the statutory process. We are currently reviewing procurement options to bring forward the remainder of the programme following completion of the statutory process.

Design work is also well underway on the A96 Dualling Inverness to Aberdeen programme. The Scottish Government intends to dual the A96 by 2030, subject to the satisfactory completion of the statutory process for each section of the dualling programme.

Question reference: S5W-27369

Asked by: Jamie Halcro Johnston, MSP for Highlands and Islands, Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party
Date lodged: Friday, 07 February 2020
Current Status: Answered by Jamie Hepburn on 26 February 2020

To ask the Scottish Government how much money from the Employability Fund has been spent in each year since 2017-18, also broken down by provider.

Employability Fund contract spend is published in the SDS Annual Procurement Reports, linked to below:

https://www.skillsdevelopmentscotland.co.uk/media/44806/annual-procurement-report-2017-2018-july-2018.pdf

https://www.skillsdevelopmentscotland.co.uk/media/45803/annual-procurement-report-2018-19.pdf

Contract Values are published and are broken down by each employability fund provider:

https://www.stf.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/employability-fund-201718-contract-values.pdf

https://www.stf.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/ef-contracts-2018-19.pdf

2019/20 contract values are not yet published, but are set out in the table below:

Employability Fund 2019-20 (Feb 2020)
Organisation	Contracted volumes	Contract Value
Aberdeen Foyer	127	£130,950
Action for Children	126	£220,650
Angus Council	38	£77,049
Apex Scotland	10	£23,373
Argyll and Bute Council	22	£50,186
Barnardo's	699	£1,440,014
Business Development Advisers Ltd	20	£32,326
CEIS Ayrshire	66	£111,816
Clackmannanshire Council	28	£44,860
Comhairle nan Eilean Siar	40	£86,358
Cornerstone Community Care	0	£3,700
Culture and Sport Glasgow	12	£36,740
Cyrenians	52	£77,800
DEAP Ltd	87	£117,210
Direct Partners Limited	69	£151,150
Doosan Babcock Ltd	8	£34,672
East Ayrshire Council	91	£178,016
ENABLE Scotland (Leading the Way)	489	£826,112
Essentials Plus Ltd	41	£70,326
Falkirk Council	228	£438,617
Fife Council	160	£258,702
First Steps Future Training Limited	30	£90,002
Galloway Training Limited	65	£171,272
GP Strategies Training Limited	87	£184,274
GTG Training Limited	166	£285,112
Helm Training Ltd	169	£374,535
IDTC Limited	208	£423,074
Impact Arts (Projects) Ltd	30	£61,619
Jim Mair Driver Training Ltd	60	£106,750
Jobs & Business Glasgow	0	£25,972
Kingdom Housing Association Limited	205	£320,518
L&G Learning (Scotland) Ltd	189	£361,231
LAMH Recycle Ltd	69	£134,136
Lanarkshire Catering School	171	£282,199
Life Skills Centres Ltd	88	£108,611
Lowland Training Services Ltd	330	£491,186
Midlothian Council - Lifelong Learning and Employability	20	£27,200
Momentum Scotland	169	£262,694
Moray College UHI	51	£62,859
Moray Council (Moray Training)	16	£24,020
Move On	41	£79,234
New College Lanarkshire	246	£529,008
Nigg Skills Academy Ltd	49	£249,621
North Edinburgh Childcare	34	£73,529
Orkney Islands Council (Orkney College)	15	£26,820
P C T Partnership Limited	6	£22,900
PeoplePlus Group Ltd	0	£17,532
Qualitas International Limited	193	£384,969
Rathbone Training	221	£1,162,448
Renfrewshire Council	43	£81,793
Right Track Scotland Ltd	230	£431,371
Routes to Work Limited	97	£182,436
Routes To Work South	249	£372,002
Rural and Urban Training Scheme Ltd	66	£128,171
Scottish Borders Council	50	£99,092
SIBBALD LTD	6	£31,130
South Ayrshire Council	68	£150,049
South Lanarkshire College	75	£161,638
South Lanarkshire Council	15	£30,563
South West Arts and Music Project (SWAMP)	50	£127,707
Station House Media Unit	52	£89,773
Stirling Council	30	£57,413
Street League	1090	£2,004,916
The Larder West Lothian	67	£132,953
The Ridge (Scotland) CIC	0	£400
The Shirlie Project	10	£14,228
The Springboard Charity	56	£88,450
The Tell Organisation Limited	420	£668,283
The Venture Trust	10	£30,572
TIGERS STA Ltd	201	£545,402
Train'd Up Railway Resourcing Limited	116	£212,900
Training for Care	38	£79,495
Training Initiatives Ltd	88	£196,843
Triage Central Ltd	471	£790,547
West Dunbartonshire Council	55	£102,950
West Highland College UHI	32	£63,624
Workers' Educational Association	20	£26,850
Working Rite	55	£107,810
Total	9101	£17,763,312

Question reference: S5W-27371

Asked by: Jamie Halcro Johnston, MSP for Highlands and Islands, Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party
Date lodged: Friday, 07 February 2020
Current Status: Answered by Jamie Hepburn on 26 February 2020

To ask the Scottish Government how much money from the Rural Supplement, delivered by Skills Development Scotland, has been spent to date, also broken down by (a) council area and (b) frameworks covered.

Skills Development Scotland report that annual spend on the Rural Supplement has been as follows:

2017-18: £939,750
2018-19: £1,034,750
2019-20 (as at 10 February 2020): £533,000

For 2017-18 and 2018-19 SDS paid a lump sum to training providers, based on a list of eligible apprentices. Consequently further breakdown is not available. Following a review with key stakeholders, eligibility criteria has been refined and is now based on the employer postcode. For 2019-20 the breakdown of spend by local authority and framework is provided in the following tables.

Local Authority*	Rural Supplement spend 2019-20 as at 10 February 2020**
Aberdeen City	£1,500
Aberdeenshire	£39,750
Angus	£1,500
Argyll & Bute	£72,250
Dumfries & Galloway	£43,750
Dundee City	£750
East Ayrshire	£4,750
East Lothian	£3,750
East Renfrewshire	£250
Glasgow City	£500
Highland	£149,250
Midlothian	£750
Moray	£15,750
Na h-Eileanan Siar	£10,250
North Ayrshire	£3,000
North Lanarkshire	£500
Orkney Islands	£21,750
Perth & Kinross	£35,500
Scottish Borders	£18,250
Shetland Islands	£47,250
South Ayrshire	£4,000
South Lanarkshire	£2,000
Stirling	£2,000
West Dunbartonshire	£4,000

Framework	Rural Supplement Spend 2019/20 as at 10 February 2020
Accounting	£750
Active Leisure, Learning and Wellbeing	£4,250
Agriculture	£12,750
Aquaculture	£23,500
Aquaculture Management Technical Apprenticeship	£2,750
Automotive	£28,500
Business & Administration	£13,250
Construction: Building	£49,250
Construction: Civil Engineering	£2,000
Construction: Technical	£10,250
Construction: Technical Apprenticeship	£2,500
Creative	£250
Creative and Digital Media	£1,000
Customer Service	£2,000
Dental Nursing	£1,000
Domestic Plumbing and Heating	£8,500
Electrical Installation	£16,500
Engineering	£30,000
Engineering Construction	£2,000
Equine	£2,250
Facilities Management	£500
Fashion & Textile Heritage	£250
Food and Drink Operations	£32,000
Freight Logistics	£18,750
Game & Wildlife Management	£1,500
Hairdressing & Barbering	£6,750
Healthcare Support	£250
Horticulture	£4,250
Hospitality	£81,750
Hospitality Management Skills Technical Apprenticeship	£26,250
Industrial Applications	£250
IT and Telecommunications	£23,500
Land-based Engineering	£3,500
Management	£15,000
Maritime Occupations	£1,750
Occupational Health & Safety Practice	£1,000
Power Distribution	£6,500
Procurement	£500
Providing Financial Services	£1,500
Retail	£8,250
Social Services (Children and Young People)	£9,000
Social Services (Children and Young People) Technical Apprenticeship	£1,250
Social Services and Healthcare	£22,000
Social Services and Healthcare Technical Apprenticeship	£3,500

* in some cases Local Authority spend has been attributed to employer HQ locations. However, clarification has been sought to ensure the employer is based within an eligible postcode area.

** The total in the above tables is £483,000 as £50,000 of claims were for an archived assignment, where, as with previous years, no local authority or framework is recorded.

Question reference: S5W-27370

Asked by: Jamie Halcro Johnston, MSP for Highlands and Islands, Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party
Date lodged: Friday, 07 February 2020
Current Status: Answered by Jamie Hepburn on 26 February 2020

To ask the Scottish Government how much money from the Flexible Workforce Development Fund has been spent in each year since 2017-18, also broken down by provider.

The following table provides a breakdown of Flexible Workforce Development Fund for the 2017-18 (£6.1m) and 2018-19 (£9.6m) Academic Years. Full information on the 2019-20 Academic Year, which is still in progress, is not available at this point.

Details are as follows:

College Region	Total Spend A/Y 2018-19
Ayrshire	£400,019
Borders	£140,220
Dumfries & Galloway	£158,998
Dundee & Angus	£473,384
Edinburgh	£1,622,273
Fife	£636,104
Forth Valley	£555,422
Glasgow	£1,936,586
Highlands & Islands	£764,103
Lanarkshire	£755,736
North East Scotland	£1,112,197
SRUC	£90,000
West	£672,000
West Lothian	£329,540
Total	£9,646,582

College Region	Total Spend A/Y 2017-18
Ayrshire College	£238,640
Borders	£110,750
Dumfries & Galloway	£48,255
Dundee & Angus	£382,877
Edinburgh	£603,923
Fife	£653,291
Forth Valley	£494,697
Glasgow	£1,067,787
Highlands & Islands	£576,745
Lanarkshire	£412,448
North East Scotland	£708,901
SRUC	£39,720
West	£536,931
West Lothian	£272,005
Total	£6,146,971

Question reference: S5W-27367

Asked by: Jamie Halcro Johnston, MSP for Highlands and Islands, Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party
Date lodged: Friday, 07 February 2020
Current Status: Answered by Jamie Hepburn on 26 February 2020

To ask the Scottish Government how much money from the Apprenticeship Levy has been spent in each year since 2017-18, also broken down by programme.

Question reference: S5W-27368

Asked by: Jamie Halcro Johnston, MSP for Highlands and Islands, Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party
Date lodged: Friday, 07 February 2020
Current Status: Answered by Jamie Hepburn on 26 February 2020

To ask the Scottish Government what proportion of funds from the Apprenticeship Levy has been spent on delivering (a) modern, (b) graduate and (c) foundation apprenticeships in each year since 2017-18.

The Scottish Government has no responsibility for the UK Government’s Apprenticeship Levy which is a tax on employers. HMRC hold data on what is raised by the Levy.

The following table sets out Scottish Government funding for Apprenticeships in the years 2017-18 and 2018-19. Figures for 2019-20 will be available at the end of the financial year.

	2017-18 (£ million)	2018-19 (£ million)
(a) Modern Apprenticeships	81.5	81.3
(b) Graduate Apprenticeships	4.7	6.1
(c) Foundation Apprenticeships	6.8	12.5

Question reference: S5W-27266

Asked by: Jamie Halcro Johnston, MSP for Highlands and Islands, Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party
Date lodged: Tuesday, 04 February 2020
Current Status: Answered by Jeane Freeman on 24 February 2020

To ask the Scottish Government which targets each NHS board has missed in each year since 2007.

For 2007-08 to 2014-15, information for those targets that were due for delivery in each year at a national level and NHS Board level is available at the UK Web Archive at the link below. Over this period, NHS Boards were also expected to deliver, on an ongoing basis, targets that been due for delivery in previous years. Consideration of whether these targets had been delivered by NHS Boards were able to be made each time data was updated in the Scotland Performs NHSScotland web pages. This was a ‘live’ system and these web pages have not been archived.

https://www.webarchive.org.uk/wayback/archive/20180707034706/
http://www.gov.scot/About/Performance/scotPerforms/NHSScotland
performance/HEATstandards

National information showing trend performance against the LDP Standards for 2015-16 onwards, and NHS Board level information for the latest period is presented in the LDP Standard pages on the current Scottish Government website. Also included in these pages are links to the statistical publications including additional data.

https://www.gov.scot/publications/nhsscotland-performance-against-ldp-standards/pages/introduction/

Data showing performance for the NHS Board targets or standards varies from monthly data to annual data and biennially data. So standards that have data available monthly could be met 12 times a year, while standards with data available annually could be met once a year.

Question reference: S5W-27269

Asked by: Jamie Halcro Johnston, MSP for Highlands and Islands, Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party
Date lodged: Tuesday, 04 February 2020
Current Status: Answered by Jamie Hepburn on 20 February 2020

To ask the Scottish Government how many applicants for modern apprenticeships have been unsuccessful in each year since 2007.

Question reference: S5W-27264

Asked by: Jamie Halcro Johnston, MSP for Highlands and Islands, Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party
Date lodged: Tuesday, 04 February 2020
Current Status: Answered by Jeane Freeman on 20 February 2020

To ask the Scottish Government how much each NHS board has spent on external private treatment in each year since 2007-08.

Seòmar agus comataidhean