The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 7503 contributions
Rural Affairs and Islands Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 14 January 2026
Finlay Carson
Okay—thank you. I will bring in Dave McKay and then take a supplementary from Alasdair Allan.
Rural Affairs and Islands Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 14 January 2026
Finlay Carson
I ask the witnesses to reserve their responses to those questions, because Beatrice Wishart has a substantive question about livestock that is pertinent to that argument. I ask Alasdair Allan to ask his substantive question, because I know that Beatrice Wishart has a question on this topic.
Rural Affairs and Islands Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 14 January 2026
Finlay Carson
Who would like to kick off on that one?
Rural Affairs and Islands Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 14 January 2026
Finlay Carson
I will bring in Dave Reay briefly and then move to supplementary questions from Ariane Burgess and Emma Roddick.
Rural Affairs and Islands Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 14 January 2026
Finlay Carson
Claire Daly wants to come in.
Rural Affairs and Islands Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 14 January 2026
Finlay Carson
We will now move to a question from Evelyn Tweed.
Rural Affairs and Islands Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 14 January 2026
Finlay Carson
Dr Eory, briefly.
Rural Affairs and Islands Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 14 January 2026
Finlay Carson
Would anyone else like to comment?
Rural Affairs and Islands Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 14 January 2026
Finlay Carson
Thank you. Tim Eagle’s question will address what happens if the approach in the plan does not work.
Rural Affairs and Islands Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 14 January 2026
Finlay Carson
It also gives me the chance to comment. Anecdotally, there are more constituents like yours, who have concerns about data capture, but, given the difficulty in changing the mythology that the marine directorate uses to calculate the health or otherwise of our rivers, they no longer come forward to suggest that we annul the instrument. However, that does not mean that there is no desire to see methods changed.
The robustness of the data is incredibly important. As we know, the present system across Scotland is generally based on rod catches. More fish tend to be caught in rivers that are fished more regularly and heavily, so they are graded higher. A good example is the River Luce in Galloway, which supports a healthy salmon population, by modern standards, that is. Whether it has been healthy historically is not clear, but it is a category 3 river. That is mostly because of the light angling effort on the river and the fact that the owners of the fishing rights only allow fly fishing, so far more fish probably get away than are caught compared with other rivers.
With a falling angling effort because of less angling, and also because of climate change affecting weather conditions, including causing droughts, it means that river gradings will be less accurate.
The national electrofishing programme for Scotland—NEPS—was developed by the marine directorate and widely welcomed. It started in 2018 and ran again in 2019. The programme did not run in 2020, because of Covid, but it was run in 2021 and 2023. It has not been operated in 2024 or 2025, due to what I understand to be a lack of funding.
There was wide recognition that NEPS was a good project that involved many trusts and those with an interest in rivers working together with the marine directorate to get a more accurate picture. That was considered along with fish counters. We heard in previous evidence sessions that the marine directorate recognised how important fish counters are. I am concerned that there has not been a roll-out of fish counters to make the data more accurate. There are also concerns that the NEPS project has not been restarted and is not attracting funding. It could remove some of the reliance on rod catch data, which is not as good as it may have been in the past.