The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 1485 contributions
Social Justice and Social Security Committee
Meeting date: 28 November 2024
Liz Smith
Mr Birt, the most recent Joseph Rowntree Foundation report, which was very interesting, was about some of the aspects of child poverty. It was very supportive of the policy that we have in Scotland, as everybody has been this morning, but you raised some interesting issues about “weaknesses” in the data, as you described it. You commented that, if the Scottish Government makes a huge commitment of £400 million-plus to a policy such as this, we must be able to drill down into the details of that policy.
What extra data would you like in order for us to be able to measure more effectively what the outcomes are when we implement a policy?
Social Justice and Social Security Committee
Meeting date: 28 November 2024
Liz Smith
Are you pointing to a quantitative lack in the data, or is there something qualitative that we need to do?
Social Justice and Social Security Committee
Meeting date: 28 November 2024
Liz Smith
Is more of that static analysis on-going now than it was before?
Social Justice and Social Security Committee
Meeting date: 28 November 2024
Liz Smith
Our witnesses last week said pretty much the same thing on that.
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 26 November 2024
Liz Smith
Are you saying that it is a little easier to estimate what the behavioural change might be for some taxes? Economists often tell us that it is incredibly difficult to measure behavioural change—I understand why—but are there taxes where it is a little bit easier to measure that?
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 26 November 2024
Liz Smith
You were hinting earlier that changes in the marginal propensity to save and consume might result from that.
In the work that you undertake with HMRC and the Scottish Fiscal Commission, do you notice any different behavioural patterns across different parts of the UK in relation to specific taxes, such as income tax?
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 26 November 2024
Liz Smith
Behavioural change, which was mentioned earlier, is a key element in deciding on policy. I know that you cannot comment at all on the policy debate but, when you examine tax, do you feel that we are getting better able to understand behavioural change?
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 26 November 2024
Liz Smith
I think that most businesses would agree that the question is difficult. There is no trustworthy evidence that people are moving away. Where there is maybe a little extra evidence is in relation to some businesses in Scotland finding it more difficult to attract people to come here—that is, recruitment is becoming increasingly difficult.
As a committee, we are interested in behavioural change that can impact on people’s decisions about how they spend their money. We are also interested in the labour market issues that we have. We have been talking a lot about economic inactivity and whether tax has an effect on it. To make a good judgment on that, it is essential that we have as much data as we possibly can. That always underlies this committee’s work, so thank you very much for your reflections on that.
Social Justice and Social Security Committee
Meeting date: 21 November 2024
Liz Smith
Could I push you a little further on that question, Mr Kelly? It is extremely important. How easy is it for you to identify where the gaps are in the national data, to improve the measurability of your policy commitments? You mentioned that you would like to see better data on employment in particular. Are there any other ways in which having better data could help in identifying how successful we are being in different areas?
09:15Social Justice and Social Security Committee
Meeting date: 21 November 2024
Liz Smith
Thank you for those extremely helpful comments, Mr Booth. Are policies likely to be more successful in tackling child poverty if they tackle poverty in general? Implicit in what you have just told the committee is the idea that it is really about helping families to get out of poverty—which, by definition, helps children. Does the data that you have collected recently show that policies to tackle the overall level of poverty are best at tackling child poverty—on top of the child payment, obviously?
Mr Booth?