The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 1485 contributions
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 7 January 2025
Liz Smith
There is a frustration, Mr Boyle. As the convener said, we have highlighted the issue several times in our reports. Mr Marra commented that Audit Scotland reports have come out recently in which it is a constant theme. We have also heard it from the Scottish Fiscal Commission. A frustration is building because if we are to have better government—I do not mean that in a party-political sense—we need to be able to have better scrutiny.
I am conscious of time, convener, so I will leave it there.
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 7 January 2025
Liz Smith
I have a quick question on your dilemma of how to ensure that more people use public transport as you try to rationalise the workforce. I represent Mid Scotland and Fife, and we have had a lot of problems with the train service in central Fife—specifically, the reduction in the numbers of carriages, because of the drivers issue. How will you go about making those two difficult pieces of the jigsaw come together?
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 7 January 2025
Liz Smith
Mr Boyle, I refer back to Mr Marra’s earlier questions, when he—quite rightly—focused on some of the concerns that we have as a committee about how we seem to be standing still. Your report “Fiscal sustainability and reform in Scotland”—particularly in paragraph 6, in which you say that you have difficulty in being able to scrutinise some aspects of the fiscal situation because you are missing documents and there is not enough transparency—encapsulates our frustrations. We have heard similar concerns from the Scottish Fiscal Commission. This committee has issued several reports over recent years setting out our real, serious difficulty in relation to the lack of transparency and accountability. Do you think that Parliament having a finance bill, which obviously we do not have right now, might help with transparency and accountability?
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 7 January 2025
Liz Smith
I have, but because we are not making any progress, I want to ask it again.
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 7 January 2025
Liz Smith
That is an interesting point, because there is a difference between having the right data available and scrutinising that data. Do you think that there are problems in both departments? Namely, is there some data lacking that we really must have to hand to enable us to be more effective in our budget scrutiny, or is there something lacking in the scrutiny process, or is it perhaps both?
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 7 January 2025
Liz Smith
They are linked.
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 7 January 2025
Liz Smith
There is pressure in upward costs. What you have cited raises costs. Balancing that against greater efficiencies is not easy, I am sure, but it is a key point.
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 7 January 2025
Liz Smith
Can I push you a little bit more? I know that you cannot make policy. However, do you think that there is evidence, perhaps from other jurisdictions, that a finance bill helps to improve the amount of time that is given to the scrutiny of the public finances?
I have heard complaints from across the political spectrum in Parliament that we are not doing enough to fully scrutinise budgets. Our committee does a huge amount of the heavy lifting on that work, for obvious reasons, and some other committees do a bit, but we are not getting the depth of scrutiny that perhaps we need. I am interested in whether you think that a finance bill might help that situation, because—let us be honest—we are standing still when it comes to the problem of transparency and we have not been able to move on.
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 7 January 2025
Liz Smith
Where is the evidence that this policy is improving investment in the housing market and the spirit of entrepreneurialism that the Scottish Government is very keen to deploy?
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 7 January 2025
Liz Smith
To be specific, where is the evidence that the policy is creating investment potential in the housing market?