The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 2544 contributions
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 12 May 2022
Willie Coffey
I understand that. Has anyone assessed the wider impact on students and staff? Is an examination of that within your scope? Is the board looking at that issue? Has anyone come to a view about the impact that the hiatus has had?
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 12 May 2022
Willie Coffey
The report also says that
“Papers for board and committee meetings held after June 2021 were not publicly available on the college’s website at the point the auditor signed their opinion on 24 March 2022.”
Has that been corrected? Is material now published online so that people can see what is going on in the college?
Local Government, Housing and Planning Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 10 May 2022
Willie Coffey
There remains the issue that Chris Ashurst perfectly described of people having their homes valued at £0 because of a process. What is your view on that, Chris? How can people find themselves in those circumstances because of a process that is not statutory?
Local Government, Housing and Planning Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 10 May 2022
Willie Coffey
Marie McNair talked about zero-valued homes and EWS1 certification. My question is for Craig Ross and Laura Hughes, who represent surveyors and insurers, respectively. Is there a legal issue if a certification scheme that has no statutory basis—and which my notes say creates particular issues in the context of Scots property law—is used to tell a homeowner that their property is valued at £0? Does hanging that value on a non-statutory process create a legal issue?
Local Government, Housing and Planning Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 10 May 2022
Willie Coffey
Laura Hughes, can you add to our understanding of the issue?
Local Government, Housing and Planning Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 10 May 2022
Willie Coffey
That is interesting. However, if a seller chose to contest that valuation, its defender would surely point to the certification process, which is non-statutory, to justify it.
Local Government, Housing and Planning Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 10 May 2022
Willie Coffey
I thank everyone for their answers, which have also covered my question on the building assessment programme.
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 28 April 2022
Willie Coffey
My questions relate to the application of quality standards in design and construction, Auditor General. As you and members are well aware, that is a common theme at the committee over many years.
The Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee took around a year to carry out its inquiry into the matter and its findings were published in December 2020. Its report, which has more than 100 pages, is full of commentary, conclusions and recommendations. Your report came out in March this year. Did you, in your analysis of the situation, make any substantive new findings compared to what the committee reported in its inquiry?
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 28 April 2022
Willie Coffey
I was just coming to that particular issue. Paragraph 50 of the report says that “CMAL could only advise” and not require Ferguson to alter its approach to design and construction. I have never heard of a quality standard worth its salt in which the customer cannot instruct the builder to carry out its wishes.
What then emerged were these owner observation reports that members will have read about in the various documents. In quality management parlance, these are change requests, which are common in any other effective quality standard. However, according to your report, there were 346 such reports, only half of which had been carried out by the time Ferguson went into administration. Was the scale of that particular outcome unusual in your experience? Was it a symptom of the failure to agree in advance the designs of this peculiar construction, effectively meaning that everyone paid the price later on in the project?
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 28 April 2022
Willie Coffey
Looking ahead, are you confident, and can you give the committee an assurance, that you can continue to make the savings that you are making and that, after the pandemic, you can continue to deliver the quality and level of care that the public in the NHS Highland area expects?