The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 2641 contributions
Social Justice and Social Security Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 15 January 2026
Bob Doris
John Dickie was right to put to us a challenge about whether the budget represents a missed opportunity, as was Hannah Randolph in relation to clarity about spend. I am taking the figures in the budget at face value, and they include an additional £150 million for whole-family support and £14 million in the tackling child poverty delivery plan. While we have the witnesses here, I want to say that those are not missed opportunities—they are actual opportunities in the year ahead.
Can you give us an idea—briefly, I am afraid, as we are short of time—of how you would like to see the additional £99 million spent to tackle child poverty? I do not want us to gloss over that significant investment.
Social Justice and Social Security Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 15 January 2026
Bob Doris
This is an appropriate time at which to come in because, in our discussion about the UK Government’s new child poverty strategy, the committee is keen to see and understand the engagement that the UK Government has had with today’s witnesses and other stakeholders in a Scottish context, in relation to not just getting information from you but having a dialogue with you as part of the process of setting its strategy. I am therefore interested in knowing what engagement each witness’s organisation has had with the UK Government and how you would describe that engagement—whether as meaningful, deep or cursory. Mr Dickie, what has the situation been like? What has your experience been?
Social Justice and Social Security Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 15 January 2026
Bob Doris
Hannah Randolph, I am not sure whether those are policy areas that the Fraser of Allander institute would engage with the UK Government on, but I would be interested to know whether that is the case.
Social Justice and Social Security Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 15 January 2026
Bob Doris
Charis, I will ask you this question first because you mentioned the child maintenance service. In relation to the Scottish and UK Governments having a positive and constructive relationship, irrespective of whether there are disagreements, I think that the cabinet secretary, when she was at the committee a few weeks ago, was a bit frustrated—I will paraphrase—because it feels as though the Scottish Government gives information to the UK Government, which goes away with it and something may or may not materialise, rather than the two Governments having an on-going substantive dialogue. The important thing is that the Scottish Government is up for that on-going substantive dialogue with the UK Government.
My final question is, if you could pick two or three things for both Governments to have a substantive and constructive dialogue on, what would they be?
Social Justice and Social Security Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 15 January 2026
Bob Doris
That is very helpful.
Social Justice and Social Security Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 15 January 2026
Bob Doris
With the convener’s permission, Mr Dickie.
Social Justice and Social Security Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 15 January 2026
Bob Doris
I have a follow-up question, and I will bring in other witnesses. The UK Government would have had to be absolutely myopic and have its fingers in its ears not to get the clamour to abolish the two-child limit, so I commend, as Marie McNair did, the work of the stakeholders of civic Scotland and the rest of the UK on that. However, I am keen to know whether there are other policy areas in which engagement resulted in a bit of movement—or whether it is still a wee bit stuck and movement has not really happened. Our committee is trying to give added value on some of that. Can you give an example beyond the removal of the two-child limit—which, obviously, we welcome?
Social Justice and Social Security Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 15 January 2026
Bob Doris
That is what my last question will be about, if there is time for it. Professor Sinclair, I do not know whether the two-child cap is an obvious example, but, based on what John Dickie said, the bandwidth and the effort that that took, for such a long period of time, might have crowded out other discussions that you were all keen to see take place. Did other discussions take place? How would you describe your engagement? Can you give some examples?
Social Justice and Social Security Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 15 January 2026
Bob Doris
Thank you, Mr Dickie—I am sorry to cut across you; it is just that I am aware of the time. Are there any additional comments on how that money could be used?
Social Justice and Social Security Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 15 January 2026
Bob Doris
That is very helpful, Mr Dickie, and a really interesting way of looking at the issue. On a slight tangent, that joint working happens quite a lot in net zero ambitions, for example, where discussions take place between Governments and, sometimes, sectoral organisations, and then a commitment is almost co-produced and announced. We perhaps do not get to see that in the field of social security and social justice. Professor Sinclair, do you have any final words?