The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 4779 contributions
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 28 October 2025
Kenneth Gibson
You were saying earlier that it has to be completed in two years and that is best practice. You aim for two years but, if it goes beyond that, that is the situation, although they must give good reasons for doing so.
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 28 October 2025
Kenneth Gibson
The public do not consider those inquiries to be particularly credible then, do they?
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 28 October 2025
Kenneth Gibson
The first witness we took evidence from for our work on public inquiries said that his inquiry, which looked into child abuse in Jersey, went back subsequently, a year or two later, to look at the effectiveness of the recommendations being implemented and what had changed. Is there any follow-up on what happens in New Zealand?
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 28 October 2025
Kenneth Gibson
Thank you for that. I will open up the session to colleagues around the table. The first will be Liz Smith, to be followed by John Mason.
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 28 October 2025
Kenneth Gibson
Your report also said that
“commissions have no specific power to compel private individuals or entities to provide them information or testimony”.
What are the implications of that? Will you also tell us about the role of the legal profession in inquiries in Sweden?
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 28 October 2025
Kenneth Gibson
I want to let my colleagues in so I do not want to go on for too much longer. I am thinking about major investigative inquiries, such as the inquiry into the MS Estonia maritime disaster, which lasted 24.9 months. Some 852 people died in that disaster, which I remember very vividly. I looked at the memorial in Tallin when the committee was in Estonia last year. For events that are as emotive as that, if you cannot compel witnesses, how difficult is it to get the kind of outcome that would be desired by the families of the victims and so on? The report talks about how the system has a very high level of public acceptance in Sweden. In cases like the Estonia disaster, how would the legal profession be involved and what would the impact of that be on the delivery of that inquiry?
09:30Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 28 October 2025
Kenneth Gibson
Thank you very much. Before we wind up, I have one final question for Professor Dahlström. The research says:
“The government is under no formal obligation to implement the inquiry’s recommendations. In practice, since policy advisory inquiries are an integrated part of the overall policy process, many inquiries have led to institutional or legislative change.”
What about investigative inquiries? In response to the adoption commission, the Swedish Government said:
“The government takes the commission’s presentation very seriously, and we will now carefully analyze their conclusions and proposals to make well-considered decisions moving forward.”
Is there a difference between policy and investigative inquiries in terms of how recommendations are implemented? It seems that policy proposals are much more likely to be implemented. Is that just my reading of it, or are the recommendations of both inquiry types being implemented effectively?
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 28 October 2025
Kenneth Gibson
Thank you for that. I ask our guests whether, in winding up, they want to make any final points or emphasise any issue or area that they feel that we have not covered yet. Dr Prasser would you like to go first?
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 28 October 2025
Kenneth Gibson
Professor Dahlström, the last word is yours.
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 28 October 2025
Kenneth Gibson
Dr Prasser, who spoke in the previous session, talked about some of the inquiries and royal commissions being a lawyers’ picnic—that it is almost like there is a dripping roast for the legal profession. He talked about folk becoming millionaires for chairing these royal commissions. I am wondering about the role of the legal profession in inquiries in New Zealand.