Skip to main content
Loading…

Seòmar agus comataidhean

Official Report: search what was said in Parliament

The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.  

Criathragan Hide all filters

Dates of parliamentary sessions
  1. Session 1: 12 May 1999 to 31 March 2003
  2. Session 2: 7 May 2003 to 2 April 2007
  3. Session 3: 9 May 2007 to 22 March 2011
  4. Session 4: 11 May 2011 to 23 March 2016
  5. Session 5: 12 May 2016 to 4 May 2021
  6. Current session: 13 May 2021 to 7 February 2026
Select which types of business to include


Select level of detail in results

Displaying 1784 contributions

|

Social Justice and Social Security Committee

Scottish Government Priorities

Meeting date: 23 September 2021

Shona Robison

I am certainly doing everything that I can, as is the Scottish Government, to leave no stone unturned. We will absolutely give it our best shot. If we manage to do all that, we will have played our part in reaching the targets.

Of course, I cannot control the impact on those targets of decisions that are made elsewhere. How frustrating would it be if the analysis suggested that we would have reached the targets had people not lost £20 a week of their universal credit? As the motto says, you can control only what you can control; we can do only what we can do, but we will work alongside the third sector and local government to do everything that we can. I absolutely give that commitment. I am confident that we will do everything that we can, but some things are just outwith our control.

10:30  

At the moment, I am worried about what I described earlier as a perfect storm. The worry of fuel poverty rates going up this winter because of rising energy bills is fast upon us; last night, I attended a Scottish Government resilience meeting in which we looked at those very issues. Again, many of the issues, such as energy caps, are reserved, and we want the UK Government to do everything it can around energy prices. The big energy companies have a role to play here, too, because we need to keep people safe over winter. As ever, the Scottish Government will step up to do what it can—you would expect nothing less—but it is a worry for people’s household incomes that all these pressures are brewing at the same time.

Social Justice and Social Security Committee

Scottish Government Priorities

Meeting date: 23 September 2021

Shona Robison

Let me make it absolutely clear: my answer to your first question is yes, and I say that without hesitation. We will do absolutely everything that we can to meet those targets. You are right to say that there were no caveats when they were set, but I think that it is fair for me to point out when progress is undermined by decisions that are made elsewhere and our task is made all the more difficult.

As for your point that social security will need to do the heavy lifting here, that is true to a degree, but I highlight the Joseph Rowntree Foundation’s comment that it is not sustainable to try to meet the child poverty targets through social security alone. Not only is that unsustainable financially, but it does not recognise the other two pillars of reducing costs and providing employment. Those are hugely important, which is why I spent a little bit of time earlier talking about the importance of game-changing interventions around employability and making it easier for parents, in particular, to get to where they want to in their lives. Employment and employment opportunities play a huge part in that.

We have said that we want to make progress on doubling the Scottish child payment as quickly as we can, and we have set that in the context of the forthcoming budget bill. I am confident that we will make progress as quickly as is humanly possible and that that will make a difference, but I also point out that it sits alongside all the other interventions for supporting families. The bridging payments, for example, have put money into the hands of families now, without our having to wait for the DWP data issues to be resolved. The payments have been a way of recognising that the issue is current and that people need the money, and they got that support into people’s hands.

However, that sits alongside the best start grant, which ensures that we help families with the cost of food, and the work that has been going on around free school meals and holiday meals, all of which is support in cash and in kind for families to keep them afloat. You can be assured that we are looking at whether there is more that we can do over the winter, because we want to do everything that we possibly can to keep families safe this winter.

Social Justice and Social Security Committee

Scottish Government Priorities

Meeting date: 23 September 2021

Shona Robison

I will get back to the committee on the timeframe in relation to the homelessness prevention duty, but we hope to do that relatively soon. Prevention is key. There is some good work being done around the ambitious rapid rehousing plans that local authorities are taking forward. There has been a sea change and a move away from the previous systems that we had towards a recognition that a housing-first approach is important for those who have additional vulnerabilities. Preventing homelessness involves local authorities and registered social landlords working with tenants who are at risk of becoming homeless.

It is not in a landlord’s interests for a tenant to lose their tenancy and end up back in the system, so a lot of preventive work has gone on, in particular with local authorities and RSLs. The pandemic has been tough and, as you will be well aware, we have worked on a number of ways of strengthening the position—the pre-action protocols, the loan fund and the grant fund—to try to ensure that people do not lose their tenancies and that we make tenancies sustainable. That is the best way of preventing homelessness. For people who have particular challenges, such as addiction issues or mental health challenges, the rapid rehousing and housing first model is definitely the way, because it gets them back into a sustainable tenancy with the wraparound support that they need.

Social Justice and Social Security Committee

Scottish Government Priorities

Meeting date: 23 September 2021

Shona Robison

Yes. It is not just about bricks and mortar, is it? It is about all the other support that someone needs. We must recognise that housing is itself an important anti-poverty measure in that it gives a safe and sustainable route for us to provide the support that the person or family needs. Whether that is support to deal with addictions, mental health problems, debt or employability, having a safe and sustainable tenancy is important to someone being able to deal with all the other issues that are in their life.

It is our ambition to supply a big number of affordable homes—110,000—but it is not only about building or acquiring new houses; it is about ensuring that people are successfully supported in those tenancies.

Social Justice and Social Security Committee

Scottish Government Priorities

Meeting date: 23 September 2021

Shona Robison

It was revealing that a UK Government adviser said—I might have used the quotation in my speech last week—that the UC cut would drive up homelessness. You can see why. If a tenancy is just—I emphasise “just”—sustainable and the tenant loses £20 a week, that can knock what was a sustainable tenancy into being unsustainable for all the reasons that we understand.

The cut will have a knock-on effect on homelessness. That is why it is absolutely wrong headed and, at this late stage, I hope that sense prevails and that, given all the other pressures, the UK Government thinks again.

Social Justice and Social Security Committee

Scottish Government Priorities

Meeting date: 23 September 2021

Shona Robison

I am always open to considering such matters. Let me say a couple of things. The housing to 2040 strategy sets out the need for barrier-free housing and the need to ensure that, rather than trying to retrofit homes, all homes are built in a way that is barrier free. That is absolutely right and proper. As we take forward the housing standard that we want to apply across all tenures, there will be opportunities to make the improvements that are needed.

We will consult on the rental sector strategy, and a housing bill will follow. There might be opportunities to make some improvements around some of those things.

If we set the target in statute, we need to be confident that it can be delivered, so there would need to be a lot of work. However, I will give that further consideration. I am also happy to have a follow-up discussion with Pam Duncan-Glancy about the case that she cited and how that might work in practice.

Social Justice and Social Security Committee

Scottish Government Priorities

Meeting date: 23 September 2021

Shona Robison

That is fine.

Social Justice and Social Security Committee

Scottish Government Priorities

Meeting date: 23 September 2021

Shona Robison

It is very challenging. We have made it clear that we want to play our part in the Afghan resettlement programme. Angus Robertson and I have been involved in a number of calls with UK ministers around Scotland playing its part and stepping up to the plate to do what we can to help people who are fleeing an intolerable situation.

The approach that we have taken is captured in “Ending Destitution Together”, which was published back in March and is a joint document between the Government and COSLA. It looks at how to improve and strengthen the provision of support and services for people living in Scotland with no recourse to public funds. The strategy is informed by powerful testimony, which I have heard myself, because I have met—virtually—a number of asylum seekers and refugees and heard directly some of their challenges.

Third sector organisations that provide front-line support are critical, as is the expertise of legal practitioners and others in supporting people and helping them to deal with trauma, for example. The strategy sets out the initial actions to deliver essential needs, which will enable access to specialist advice and advocacy.

In answer to the convener’s other question, we will continue to press the UK Government to make changes to reduce the risk of people falling into destitution as a result of their immigration status. There are very strict rules; someone’s ability to remain here can be jeopardised if they get access to public funds that are regarded as not being acceptable or as breaching the rules. There needs to be caution in that respect. We have also specifically asked the UK Government to remove the Scottish welfare fund from the list of restricted public funds, as that would give us a flexible way of helping people in crisis. Unfortunately, we have not yet reached any agreement on that, but we will continue to pursue the matter.

11:00  

Social Justice and Social Security Committee

Scottish Government Priorities

Meeting date: 23 September 2021

Shona Robison

Thank you, convener, and good morning, everyone. It seems strange being in this position, given that I used to be a committee member, but it is nice to be back for the first time in this role.

As the programme for government made clear, the Scottish Government has an ambitious schedule of work ahead on social justice and social security, and I would like to update the committee briefly on some priority areas, including driving forward our national mission to tackle child poverty and our social security programme as well as combating homelessness and violence against women and girls.

First, on child poverty, we will publish in March our second tackling child poverty delivery plan, which will set out ambitious actions across the three drivers of poverty to deliver our interim targets and will be backed by a further £50 million fund.

We are on track to deliver the Scottish child payment to under-16s by the end of 2022, subject to United Kingdom Government co-operation. We will also double the payment to £20 a week as soon as we can in this session, and we will set out details of exactly when and how when we publish the budget bill. To ensure that we are immediately reaching around 148,000 young people, we are making bridging payments of £520 a year to children who receive free school meals. We’ve already paid out £200 of this year’s total and agreed dates with the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities for the next two £160 payments in October and December. That, of course, stands in contrast to the UK Government, which in a week’s time will cut universal credit by £20 per week, meaning a loss of over £1,000 a year for 6 million households.

We are determined to build a social security system that is based on dignity, fairness and respect. Delivery remains a joint enterprise with the Department for Work and Pensions, and I am grateful to the department for its support and recent constructive ministerial discussions.

The challenges of large-scale benefit delivery are well known. For example, although the UK Government’s universal credit was originally supposed to be fully rolled out by 2017, that roll-out is more likely to take until 2026. We are proud that, in the three years since we got the powers and legislative ability to deliver benefits, we have introduced 11 benefits, seven of which are brand new. When all benefits are introduced and we have transferred all clients from the DWP to our Scottish systems, we will be delivering 17 benefits, six more than were originally anticipated.

This parliamentary session will see more milestones reached. From 22 November, child disability payment, our first disability benefit, will roll out nationally, and from mid-October, we will begin to transfer awards for Scottish clients currently receiving disability living allowance for children on to that payment. Moreover, from the end of November, we will pay child winter heating assistance for the second year, extending eligibility to severely disabled young people who receive personal independence payments.

If our Carer’s Allowance Supplement (Scotland) Bill passes, we will make a double payment of the supplement in December, totalling £462.80. I thank the committee for carrying out its work on the bill in what was a very short timeframe.

Next year, we will launch the adult disability payment, which will replace the personal independence payment, and begin transferring around 300,000 Scottish clients on to our new benefit. Thereafter, my immediate priorities will be delivering Scottish carers assistance—on which we are working with the DWP to agree a timetable—and our winter heating benefits. Following discussions with the DWP, we will start in winter 2022 with our new annual £50 winter heating payment, which will specifically be for low-income households that are currently eligible for cold weather payments. That will be followed by pension-age winter heating assistance, which will mirror the current winter fuel payment and is provisionally scheduled for winter 2024.

That is clearly a packed programme requiring significant amounts of legislation, and I am grateful for the committee’s support. When all those benefits are rolled out, we will reach 1.8 million people—around one person in three in Scotland. Social Security Scotland is preparing for that now. It expects to recruit more than 2,000 permanent employees over the next year and, by autumn next year, it will directly employ more than 3,500 people. That recruitment provides secure, long-term employment in Dundee and Glasgow and across the country through our local delivery service, boosting economic opportunities for communities throughout Scotland. I hope that that will be welcomed by all.

I am pleased that members of the committee have joined our cross-party steering group to take forward a minimum income guarantee, which is potentially revolutionary. We are also acting decisively to tackle homelessness and rough sleeping, investing £50 million this parliamentary session in a new ending homelessness together fund. We are also investing more than £100 million to support front-line services and prevent violence against women and girls through our equally safe fund and other measures.

I am happy to take any questions.

Social Justice and Social Security Committee

Scottish Government Priorities

Meeting date: 23 September 2021

Shona Robison

I look forward to working with you on many of these areas of joint responsibility and interest.

As I laid out in my opening remarks, Social Security Scotland has been building up over time, but it is clear that there needs to be a significant increase in staffing, not least with the transfer of the disability benefits. Therefore, we are heading towards a staffing complement of around 3,500 to ensure that the agency has the capacity to deliver the type of service that we want to deliver for clients. That is good not only for clients but for the local economies not only in Dundee and Glasgow but throughout Scotland, where local teams will give a direct face-to-face service to people.

I ask Alison Byrne to say something more about the pace of build-up in the staffing complement.