The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 923 contributions
Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Meeting date: 1 December 2022
Sarah Boyack
Professor Reid, do you want to come in on that? It is unusual to have a bill in front of us with other bits of legislation being used to say that we should not worry about the bill because these other bits of legislation might help. We do not have the detail of those bits of legislation, either. Is that approach unprecedented?
Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Meeting date: 1 December 2022
Sarah Boyack
I thank the witnesses for all the written evidence that we have in front of us today. It has been really helpful, and I would just like to explore some of the issues raised in it.
Over the past couple of weeks, we have heard about the lack of clarity, the uncertainty and the complexity around the cliff edge for the legislation and its impact on producers and businesses. Everybody has mentioned the environment, but I wonder whether you can give us some examples in that respect. I know that David MacKenzie has talked about the impact on communities, but I would like to go to Isobel Mercer and the RSPB first for some examples; its submission talks about the habitats directive, air quality and water quality, while others have talked about chemicals. How will the bill impact on those areas and what legislation is potentially at risk?
Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Meeting date: 1 December 2022
Sarah Boyack
What will be the intended process for actually retaining law? We have talked about the scale of all this, but what does that actually mean? What is the process for saving a piece of legislation as currently construed by the bill?
Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Meeting date: 1 December 2022
Sarah Boyack
That was very helpful.
Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Meeting date: 1 December 2022
Sarah Boyack
We have heard that the Soil Association has concerns, too. David, can you say a bit more about the impact of losing some of the regulatory or legal environment on water quality and pesticides?
Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Meeting date: 1 December 2022
Sarah Boyack
I want to follow up on that point. RSPB Scotland made a point about uncertainty in its evidence, and about the fact that although ministers have given reassurances about the devolution settlement in various pieces of UK legislation, there is the chilling effect that you just talked about.
How can we have certainty? I will go to Isobel Mercer first. Reassurances have been given in the Levelling Up and Regeneration Bill and in the Environment Act 2021. However, if those are just words, what will be the legal impact, given the uncertainty and bodies not being prepared to push the envelope because they are worried about legal status?
Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Meeting date: 1 December 2022
Sarah Boyack
But if all that is going to be implemented on the ground, what will be the reality check?
Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Meeting date: 1 December 2022
Sarah Boyack
Professor Reid, do you want to come in on that point? Your evidence about the sheer scale of the legislation on the environment alone is really quite powerful.
Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Meeting date: 1 December 2022
Sarah Boyack
We have been told that the dashboard is not up to date. Do you have any comment on that from a legal perspective?
Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Meeting date: 1 December 2022
Sarah Boyack
Thank you. That was really helpful. It is very much what the Law Society of Scotland said when we discussed the matter a couple of weeks ago.