The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 1714 contributions
Meeting of the Parliament
Meeting date: 13 November 2024
Christine Grahame
Will the cabinet secretary take an intervention?
Meeting of the Parliament
Meeting date: 12 November 2024
Christine Grahame
Good housing is central to health and wellbeing, but it is difficult in rural areas, such as the Scottish Borders, to have house builders engage in small developments. Some communities might feel that they will be sidestepped in the interests of accelerated house building, and many, as we know, only become engaged in the planning process late in the day.
I welcome reference to Planning Aid Scotland. Frankly, local members should be well aware of its functions, but most of the public are not. What can the Scottish Government do to help communities to engage with Planning Aid?
Meeting of the Parliament
Meeting date: 7 November 2024
Christine Grahame
I would like to get on. Is it about the veterinary agreement? [Interruption.] Is this a benefit?
Meeting of the Parliament
Meeting date: 7 November 2024
Christine Grahame
That was more of a speech, and it was not really worth it. When you think of the tax that is now being levied on the whisky industry, which the sector is up in arms about, and the levies that the USA is about—[Interruption.] I am coming to the lovely Tories. As I was saying, 10 to 20 per cent tariffs on whisky exports to the USA might be coming. I cannot see that as a benefit of Brexit.
I return to the veterinary agreement, which Tim Eagle did not want me to talk about. Such an agreement would ensure that UK and EU standards were equivalent or aligned. That is important for animal welfare, the biosecurity of plants and so on. The Labour Party made a manifesto commitment to pursue such an agreement, which would aid a new trading relationship with the EU. For many years, the Scottish Government has called for a comprehensive veterinary and sanitary and phytosanitary agreement, which would substantially reduce the barriers to trade that have been put in place following Brexit. I hear that the cabinet secretary is hopeful that that will come to pass. Let us watch this space.
I have lost my speech now—excuse me a minute. I never should tamper with technology. Oh, something strange has appeared. I will go back to it.
Meeting of the Parliament
Meeting date: 7 November 2024
Christine Grahame
I am going to. I have a paper back-up.
I have not had time to mention national insurance or agricultural property tax relief. That would have been an attack on Labour—it deserves it, too.
When it comes to the good news, I have a problem. While any Government in this Parliament has to rely on the bulk of its budget coming from Westminster, while macroeconomic policies such as national insurance and inheritance tax are reserved and while the UK Government has ruled out rejoining the EU in any shape or form, there is very little good news on Brexit until we are—here is the word that the Tories like—independent and can rejoin the EU. Frankly, I agree with George Osborne and his dire predictions.
Meeting of the Parliament
Meeting date: 7 November 2024
Christine Grahame
I will shortly.
Furthermore, rather than our having that £350 million a week Brexit bonus that we saw on the side of a bus, the UK Treasury has been forced to admit that the UK has already paid to the EU £23.8 billion as part of its financial settlement agreement and will pay a further £6.4 billion. I do not call that a benefit.
Then there was the Boris battle cry that, after Brexit, the UK could control immigration. How has that gone? As a matter of fact, immigration from the EU was largely economic, based on job seeking, which is much less true of immigration from outside the EU.
I say to Tim Eagle that the present and the future are predicated on the past. No wonder he and the Tories have lodged an amendment that would delete from the motion any reference to Brexit.
The rural sector, like others, is feeling the impact of Brexit—one that Labour will not reverse. That sector comprises 26 per cent of Scotland’s economy.
Meeting of the Parliament
Meeting date: 7 November 2024
Christine Grahame
I will, but a little bit later, Mr Eagle, if you do not mind.
The rural economy puts food on our plates, leads the fight against climate change and nature loss, and delivers significant value for taxpayers’ investment. Rural businesses are at the forefront of our efforts to tackle the nature and climate crisis, and, at the same time, they provide jobs that boost our economy and support Scotland’s food economy. It is a fantastic sector. Rural businesses are the custodians of the land that they farm, and, if only on that, I agree with that part of Mr Eagle’s amendment.
I turn to the labour market. Much of the rural economy was dependent on EU workers, who were often seasonal. That has pretty well ended, and we have heard of produce dying and rotting in the fields for want of labour. Is that one of the benefits of Brexit, Mr Hoy?
I turn to the possible veterinary agreement with the EU.
Meeting of the Parliament
Meeting date: 7 November 2024
Christine Grahame
Is it a Brexit benefit, Mr Eagle?
Meeting of the Parliament
Meeting date: 7 November 2024
Christine Grahame
I was pondering, but I think that I will.
Meeting of the Parliament
Meeting date: 7 November 2024
Christine Grahame
Oh, Mr Eagle is going to tell me a benefit—good.