The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 1416 contributions
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 16 June 2022
Sharon Dowey
So CMAL was aware of the issue before it was announced that you had the contract.
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 16 June 2022
Sharon Dowey
Had you not taken the contract for the two vessels, did you have enough work at the yard to make it viable? Would you have survived if you had not taken that contract?
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 9 June 2022
Sharon Dowey
Paragraph 105 on page 45 of the report states:
“in March 2021 the Scottish Government finalised the arrangements to fund and manage the vessels ... This included replacing the existing fixed-price contract between CMAL and FMPG with a new contract (for each vessel) between itself and FMPG. The Scottish Government is committed to paying the additional vessel costs, regardless of the final price.”
You have just said that you are looking for something at as low a cost as possible. Is it normal for the Scottish Government to hand a contractor a blank cheque?
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 9 June 2022
Sharon Dowey
Can you come back to us with the actual dates?
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 9 June 2022
Sharon Dowey
Finally, at what stage in the procurement process did the Scottish Government, Transport Scotland and Scottish ministers first become aware that FMEL was unable to offer a full builders refund guarantee?
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 9 June 2022
Sharon Dowey
At what point did ministers become aware that the BRG was not in place?
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 9 June 2022
Sharon Dowey
We just want to know when everybody actually knew this. Last week, I was sitting here saying that all this might have been rushed, but obviously there is a question about whether they were trying to rush it because an announcement was going to be made at the yard at the end of August when CMAL was still in negotiations. I just want to try to clarify the point at which each—
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 9 June 2022
Sharon Dowey
Okay. Thank you.
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 9 June 2022
Sharon Dowey
In your opening statement, you said that you accepted all the recommendations in the Audit Scotland report. Can I double check that that is the case? Are there any recommendations in that report that you have any reservations about?
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 9 June 2022
Sharon Dowey
Good morning. Paragraphs 104 to 109 of the report, starting on page 45, outline how the Scottish Government has fundamentally changed the arrangements to complete the vessels since the shipyard was brought into public ownership in December 2019. That includes the appointment of Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd as its technical consultant.
During the Public Audit Committee’s evidence session with the Auditor General for Scotland on 28 April 2022, he commented on the new arrangements, stating:
“There is no denying that the arrangements are unusual. That paragraph also notes that Transport Scotland no longer has a role in the delivery of the ships. That is quite distinct from where we were.”—[Official Report, Public Audit Committee, 28 April 2022; c 37.]
Under the new arrangements to complete the vessels, CMAL has been appointed as the Scottish Government’s technical consultant and Transport Scotland no longer has a role in the delivery of the ships. Why were those decisions taken? What work was undertaken to assess the risks associated with the change in roles?