The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 1202 contributions
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 13 January 2026
Craig Hoy
The most recent available data, which was provided to the committee by the Scottish Fiscal Commission, said that, in the rest of the UK, 16 per cent of people were coming off the benefit at the annual review, whereas, in Scotland, the figure was 2 per cent, which is a very significant gap to close. What are the long-term budgetary risks if Scotland does not manage to perform broadly in line with the rest of the UK?
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 6 January 2026
Craig Hoy
I have a specific question in relation to members’ accommodation. Thinking about those members who rent a flat—which, in some respects, might be a more efficient approach for those who live further afield—I note that councils can now charge double council tax and that, as a result of recent legislation, that multiplier has been extended. Is that one of the issues that you will be looking into? Is it putting pressure on accommodation allowances, given that £2,000 to £3,000 is potentially being added?
Finally, the legislation that allows for the doubling of council tax exempts those who require two properties for the purpose of employment. That will cover a Church of Scotland minister living in a manse, but not an MSP who happens to live in the Highlands but works three days a week in Edinburgh. Have you made any representations in that respect?
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 6 January 2026
Craig Hoy
Do you accept the principle that by reducing a tax or eliminating it altogether, you can achieve a positive outcome?
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 6 January 2026
Craig Hoy
Good morning, Mr Carlaw. You will be aware that, throughout Government now, there is real pressure to look at making efficiency savings. In your evidence, you have talked about the possibility of a 5 per cent increase in productivity, because of the shorter working week, and the possibility of carrying a 5 per cent vacancy rate. Does that suggest that, in the past, we might not have been as efficient as we could have been? How much further and faster can you go in trying to make efficiency savings in future years?
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 6 January 2026
Craig Hoy
My next question links to that point in relation to pressures on MSPs’ offices. The flipside of the use of technology is that we are all receiving far more automated requests, particularly on emotive issues such as euthanasia, gender, animal welfare and so on. The Westminster staff support budget is now somewhere in the region of £280,000 per year for MPs who are not based in London. As with the point that Jackson Carlaw made, MSPs seem to have fallen behind. I am not necessarily advocating for an increase in MSPs’ office cost allowances, but what benchmarking has the corporate body done over time to see whether the staff cost provision is keeping up with, for example, the Westminster Parliament?
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 6 January 2026
Craig Hoy
Absolutely.
I will ask about some of the grander areas of spending. It appears that restaurant services potentially cost £0.8 million—
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 6 January 2026
Craig Hoy
Nor might you, Mr Carlaw.
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 6 January 2026
Craig Hoy
Good morning. For the record, in relation to the structure of investment zones and the way in which this relief will apply in Scotland, are those broadly comparable or an absolute replica of the way in which investment zones in England are applying reliefs on stamp duty?
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 6 January 2026
Craig Hoy
Fine. Lastly, minister, implicit—or, perhaps, explicit—in this is an acceptance that you can achieve behavioural change in the corporate environment by reducing or eliminating taxes. Looking at the structure of LBTT in a corporate environment, would it be a goal of the Government to try to make sure that there were greater incentives to bring those sorts of developments to Scotland than the incentives in other parts of the UK? At this point, what assessment have you made of the competitiveness of the LBTT structure versus the full stamp duty regime in England?
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 6 January 2026
Craig Hoy
In relation to SPICe, have you been able to assess how many referrals from members for research happen year on year? If AI will assist with that, what would happen in relation to the head count moving forward? Would increased demand from members require maintaining a stable workforce even though AI can do some of the hard graft of research?