The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 928 contributions
Rural Affairs and Islands Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 11 March 2026
Emma Roddick
I understand why it would need to be done in collaboration with the industry, but I was quite concerned by the responses on escapes in the previous evidence session on salmon farming. A couple of quite large escapes had been discussed in a bit of detail, and regulators were asked questions on whether particular changes were needed, whether there were systemic issues and how that related to potential interaction with wild salmon. It seemed that they were relying on industry monitoring and industry opinion on what needed to happen next. Is that enough? When so many regulators are involved in a particular policy area, should one of them not be taking the lead, rather than the industry, on checking whether interactions have occurred and what the industry should do to prevent them?
Rural Affairs and Islands Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 11 March 2026
Emma Roddick
It would be really good to see progress made on that.
The other point that Fisheries Management Scotland raised in that session was about the apparent gap in reporting escapes. There was a reference to a wellboat escape that was not captured in the aquaculture database. It seems that some interactions are still not being monitored or that fisheries boards are not aware of them, because there is a gap.
Rural Affairs and Islands Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 11 March 2026
Emma Roddick
However, if we still do not know enough, should the research piece not come before the development of new farms?
Rural Affairs and Islands Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 11 March 2026
Emma Roddick
Does that work for both parties, though? Does it make sense to just carry on and not to commit any further forward than the current moment?
Rural Affairs and Islands Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 11 March 2026
Emma Roddick
Has there been an assessment of any costs that could be incurred as a result of not continuing schemes?
Rural Affairs and Islands Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 11 March 2026
Emma Roddick
In the last session, Professor Dwyer said that having mandatory mortality reporting is important in relation to livestock welfare issues. Given that it is clear that a lot of data on mortalities is collected at the site level and that, in many cases, that data also includes the cause of death, including for cleaner fish, do you agree that that data should be published by the marine directorate?
Rural Affairs and Islands Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 11 March 2026
Emma Roddick
Cabinet secretary, I am concerned that the mortality figures that we are scrutinising are still incomplete. We still cannot see mortality figures in freshwater during transport, during the six-week transfer period or, as you mentioned, for cleaner fish during culling. How can we accurately measure how ethical and sustainable the industry is if we are seeing only one small part of the mortality picture?
Rural Affairs and Islands Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 11 March 2026
Emma Roddick
Going back to the cabinet secretary’s—
Rural Affairs and Islands Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 11 March 2026
Emma Roddick
I am concerned about what is going on. I have just read the Scottish Government’s press release on why it is in everybody’s best interests to manage mortality in salmon farms. It sounds as though we are saying, “The farmers are experiencing mass mortality events and are trying to do something about them, but it is outwith their control.” Surely that does not make it better from an animal welfare point of view. It does not mean that fish have not died or that fish will not die in a few weeks’ time when the same uncontrollable event happens, either in the same place or somewhere further up the coast. Surely we need to look at the situation from an ethical standpoint, because fish keep dying and we cannot stop it.
Rural Affairs and Islands Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 11 March 2026
Emma Roddick
Do we know the extent of any environmental and interactions impacts?