The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 2839 contributions
COVID-19 Recovery Committee
Meeting date: 2 December 2021
Jim Fairlie
As I said, I know that we have been over the issue before, but it is worth re-emphasising.
COVID-19 Recovery Committee
Meeting date: 2 December 2021
Jim Fairlie
I want to come back to Michael Clancy on the point that he just made. The Civil Contingencies Act 2004 was brought in following the foot and mouth outbreak in 2001 to prevent people’s access to the countryside and farms. Is that a UK act, and does the Scottish Government have any access to it? Is it reserved or can the Scottish Government use it?
Rural Affairs, Islands and Natural Environment Committee
Meeting date: 1 December 2021
Jim Fairlie
Sorry, convener—I thought that other members of the panel were going to come in.
I want to touch on the farming community. My question is probably to all four witnesses, who will be aware of the tensions between forestry and farming. I constantly hear that it is either forestry or farming, but not both. A lot of the questions that are put to me are about the science behind the carbon storage of forestry as opposed to naturally grazed land. The buying power of forestry is pushing the price of hill land up beyond its current levels, which makes it absolutely unbuyable for farming. What work has been done by the forestry industry to get to grips with the integration of farming and forestry, so that the two things can work together and cohabit?
Is it true that Forestry Scotland is enabling greenwashing in Scotland? Is it the case that when private investors come in, we lose the value of that natural capital in Scotland?
This question is probably just for David Signorini. Are you able to help farmers who want to plant orchards? Although I know that it is outwith the scope of the current forestry plan, is there a way for you to bring in orchards so that farmers can grow trees and still get a crop out of the land and can potentially graze it as well?
I know that there is a lot in there, but that is a constant theme that comes back to me in the farming community in which I live.
Rural Affairs, Islands and Natural Environment Committee
Meeting date: 1 December 2021
Jim Fairlie
Which is what?
Rural Affairs, Islands and Natural Environment Committee
Meeting date: 1 December 2021
Jim Fairlie
You mentioned hedgerows. Do you include hedgerows in the baseline carbon audit of a farm?
Rural Affairs, Islands and Natural Environment Committee
Meeting date: 1 December 2021
Jim Fairlie
I echo what you just said, Grant. There must be far more integration and the farming community must be taken along with that project.
At the moment, there are undoubtedly real tensions. I keep being sent articles that say that grazed land will sequestrate as much carbon as forestry or that trees will do more damage and it takes 25 years to get it back, for example. However, you are right that there is far more to the matter than carbon sequestration. What you and David Signorini said gives me some comfort that you will start to consider the matter much more holistically so that the farming community is part of the process, as opposed to it being a case of forestry against farming.
I asked David Signorini whether Scottish Forestry is able to allow farmers to plant orchards, which are far more open, on their farms. I know that it is not workable with the current system, but does Scottish Forestry have the power to integrate such planting on farms? We talk about regenerative farming and one of the things that we are supposed to be doing is ensuring that we have good woodland. We cannot just put it to the side and leave it as done. If there is an opportunity to be able to graze in between it and get another crop off it, that must surely be beneficial for a regenerative farming system.
12:00Rural Affairs, Islands and Natural Environment Committee
Meeting date: 1 December 2021
Jim Fairlie
Sorry, David—I am giving you a grilling here. How do you answer the accusation that Scottish Forestry is allowing private investors to greenwash the businesses that they run when they are not changing them?
Rural Affairs, Islands and Natural Environment Committee
Meeting date: 1 December 2021
Jim Fairlie
I am afraid that you are getting another question. As somebody who knows nothing about fishing, it sounds a wee bit like the wild west out there.
You said that you were funded by the EU on a two-year project. How much was that funding, and who did you say you applied to afterwards for funding, when your application was refused? I missed that last bit.
Rural Affairs, Islands and Natural Environment Committee
Meeting date: 1 December 2021
Jim Fairlie
Thank you.
COVID-19 Recovery Committee
Meeting date: 25 November 2021
Jim Fairlie
I left the best until last.