The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 2063 contributions
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 19 November 2024
Michelle Thomson
The third area of potential risk is AI-enabled cyberattacks, which have become increasingly more sophisticated. Is that something that you expect your new digital person to consider in more detail?
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 19 November 2024
Michelle Thomson
You knew that I was going to ask about the board, so thank you for bringing that in, too.
That is me as far as my questions are concerned, unless you have anything to add, Aidan O’Carroll.
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 19 November 2024
Michelle Thomson
You have already answered my follow-on question. That was fairly well documented.
This is a question that I asked you last year, but I will ask it again, because I am going to put it to every public body that comes in front of me at any committee. How are you preparing for the potentially exponential growth in the use of artificial intelligence? What is your thinking this year compared with last year? What external consultants are you using, and what is your risk assessment? This is just a checkpoint.
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 19 November 2024
Michelle Thomson
I regard the fact that that keeps you awake as good news.
We have talked about your risk assessment in general. In the context of the constraints in public sector funding, you have already commented in response to a number of questions about things that you cannot really afford to spend on. You just referenced the Scottish Government’s human resources and finance corporate transformation programme. Are you alluding to the possibility that that could mean further restrictions or lack of growth in funding or is it as much about what that might bring to you? I am interested to hear a bit more about that.
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 19 November 2024
Michelle Thomson
Lastly, every time that you come in front of us, you always talk very positively about the culture that you are fostering. I regard culture in organisations as hugely important and, of course, something that comes from the top. Often, the culture of an organisation stays endemic to it, even after the original people have moved on to different things. What is your guiding philosophy? What are, if you like, the top trees that you are planting that will grow and bloom for generations after we have all moved on?
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 19 November 2024
Michelle Thomson
The convener mentioned the public trust model. Might it be beneficial to work cross-party on that? It strikes me that, if a sound model can be found and adopted, it would have potential benefits for a variety of areas, given current constraints. A few members might be interested in looking at the implications of that generally, but it would also be advantageous for your bill.
Economy and Fair Work Committee
Meeting date: 13 November 2024
Michelle Thomson
Yes, I appreciate the commercial sensitivity; I am fully mindful of that. However, I think that having more public information as to the specific implications with regard to the hydrocracker, and why we are in the current position, would be helpful for the public record.
In addition, I have not seen a public impact assessment of an import terminal. I do not know whether you have undertaken such an assessment, but it would be useful to understand the top-line impacts on environmental security and, in particular, the societal impacts. I draw your attention to the recent commentary from John Bell of Gulfsands, which you will probably have seen. He believes that the impact is significant, and that has been backed up by the PwC report.
Have you undertaken an impact assessment? What can you put in the public domain regarding the implications of the import terminal?
Economy and Fair Work Committee
Meeting date: 13 November 2024
Michelle Thomson
Have you conducted an internal assessment of the hydrocracker and the hydrogen unit that feeds it? Are you able to share that with the committee at all?
11:00Economy and Fair Work Committee
Meeting date: 13 November 2024
Michelle Thomson
I know that other members are going to come in with more detail on a lot of these questions. On Grangemouth in particular, the community has a multitude of issues. The committee’s general sense, as we brought out in our earlier report, was that the community had gained no material benefit from the carbon revolution, and that it has concerns about a just transition.
I understand what you are saying about profit margins and the future direction of travel, but what would need to happen in order for both Ineos and Petroineos, and PetroChina, to pause the plans for the refinery to allow more substantive steps to be taken to enable a just transition?
I fully understand the direction of travel, but what would need to happen for there to be a pause? I think that that is what most people are looking for.
Economy and Fair Work Committee
Meeting date: 13 November 2024
Michelle Thomson
Thank you for being very clear about that. My final question is whether you have specifically asked the UK Government for financial support or, indeed, whether the need for it has been discussed at any point up to today. In other words, could there be any doubt in its mind that that could still have been an incentive to bring about a pause, as I have discussed?