The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 3918 contributions
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 25 June 2025
Richard Leonard
Jamie Greene has a question about Circularity Scotland before we move on.
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 25 June 2025
Richard Leonard
During the course of this morning’s meeting, we will probe those areas a little bit more. The environment in which you operate is one of the issues that is highlighted in the Audit Scotland report; it is certainly something that members of the committee want to ask the two of you about.
I invite Graham Simpson to open this morning’s questioning.
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 25 June 2025
Richard Leonard
Funnily enough, the deputy convener has some questions in this area, too, as well as some others. Over to you, Jamie.
Meeting of the Commission
Meeting date: 23 June 2025
Richard Leonard
But they are not like health and safety inspectors, who turn up unannounced, are they? I would expect that an audit is a planned operation between the public body that is being audited and the auditor—whether they are internal or from an external firm—who is carrying out the audit.
Meeting of the Commission
Meeting date: 23 June 2025
Richard Leonard
Might you come back next year and share with us another quite big variance in the fees paid, compared to the budget that has been set?
Meeting of the Commission
Meeting date: 23 June 2025
Richard Leonard
Before you bring in Owen Smith, can you expand not just on “late”—we all understand “late” and that there may be understandable reasons for lateness in the completion of an audit—but the expression “not making progress”? That is of much greater concern to me than audits being late.
Meeting of the Commission
Meeting date: 23 June 2025
Richard Leonard
In paragraph 18 of the report, you refer to one outlier public body, which has not had its audit for the financial year 2022-23 completed and, therefore, not had one completed for 2023-24 and, therefore, not had one completed for 2024-25. Again, that rings alarm bells with me, both as convener of the Public Audit Committee and as a member of the commission. In the end, this is about public money. It is about assurance for that body, and the good governance of that body. I do not know how big that particular organisation is, but nonetheless we are talking about whether a proper audit of public money is being undertaken.
Meeting of the Commission
Meeting date: 23 June 2025
Richard Leonard
Excellent.
Meeting of the Commission
Meeting date: 23 June 2025
Richard Leonard
Perhaps I can finish where I started, by going back to your figures, which say that 91 audits are late—or, to use Mr Smith’s terminology, “not making progress” according to his yardstick. However, you also give us a breakdown that, of those 91 cases, 46 are late due to the auditor, 27 are due late to the body that is being audited and 18 are late in circumstances that are “beyond the control of either”. Again, that is your explanation. I am not quite sure what “beyond the control of either” means. How can something be beyond the control of either the auditor or the public body that is being audited? That baffles me.
Meeting of the Commission
Meeting date: 23 June 2025
Richard Leonard
I am sorry—that just reminds me of the narrative that we get on Ferguson Marine, which is that to get the Glen Sannox afloat we have to jeopardise progress on the Glen Rosa, through retrofitting parts from the Glen Rosa on to the Glen Sannox so that at least that vessel is afloat. However, what you described does not solve the problem of what is happening with the public body whose audit is being considerably delayed and jeopardised, does it? I understand that that is the way of working. The reason that I am making facial expressions is because it just reminds me of what we get told on other aspects of audit.