The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 3697 contributions
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 14 March 2023
John Mason
Professor Cairney, your paper is full of contrasts or, some would say, paradoxes. Colleagues have mentioned a few, and I will mention a few more.
Under the heading “Fostering equity, fairness, or justice”, you talk about the focus
“on efficiency, using economic tools … to identify how to produce the highest benefits from the same costs”,
but you say that policy
“should also prioritise the fair distribution of costs and benefits.”
Is it not possible to be efficient and fair?
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 14 March 2023
John Mason
That touches on one of the other issues that I want to raise, which is mentioned later in your report. It concerns the idea of decentralisation, flexibility, collaborative working and all those sorts of things, as against setting a clear ambition for national accountability.
I suppose that I would feel that that is the case; you can either go too far one way or too far the other. If there is a clear, driving ambition from central Government, that means that local government and everyone else will get squashed. On the other hand, however, if you allow local government—or local health boards or local anything—to do whatever it wants, there is no coherence to that. I feel that, ultimately, that is impossible to square.
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 14 March 2023
John Mason
Everything that you say leads to more possible questions, but I will ask you just one more. I go back to what you say in your report, under the heading “Responsible and accountable government”, with regard to who the MSPs and elected members are. You say that there should be “a clear link between” how the citizens vote and members of Parliament, and therefore the Executive. I do not know whether we have that at the moment.
I am more interested in the second bullet point, in which you refer to
“The recruitment of elected politicians from a diverse pool of candidates, to boost the representativeness of parliaments in relation to social background.”
We have tried to get a balance between men and women. What could we do to really get a cross-section of society in Parliament? Is that another impossibility?
10:45Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 14 March 2023
John Mason
Okay. I shall restrain myself from asking anything else.
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 14 March 2023
John Mason
So it is fairer to invest in all the kids aged two or three, but we still need some high-quality graduates and, therefore, to be efficient as a country, we have to invest. Is that the contrast?
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 14 March 2023
John Mason
I get that. We could spend ages discussing what “fair” is and so on. I will leave that.
Near the beginning of your report, under the heading “What do ‘effective government’ principles mean in practice?”, you talk about the “wide range of ... ambitions” that we have in Scotland, and you go on to list some of them. Do we have too many ambitions? Is one of the problems that we are trying to do too many things?
COVID-19 Recovery Committee
Meeting date: 9 March 2023
John Mason
Right. I will come to Dr Scott next.
COVID-19 Recovery Committee
Meeting date: 9 March 2023
John Mason
I will continue Brian Whittle’s line of questioning. We have heard different evidence from down south. Is one of the problems that some GPs are not familiar with the codes, which is why they are going through the free text route? I am not a medic or a scientist, so will you explain what free text is?
COVID-19 Recovery Committee
Meeting date: 9 March 2023
John Mason
On the point about face-to-face meetings with people, does that vary between different health boards in Scotland? Do some do more face-to-face meetings than others, or is it a national problem?
COVID-19 Recovery Committee
Meeting date: 9 March 2023
John Mason
Okay. I have a question for Dr Scott, but I think that she wants to comment on the previous question first.