The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 2547 contributions
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 1 June 2023
Willie Coffey
Do both the Scottish Government and Ferguson’s accept the findings of the section 22 report?
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 1 June 2023
Willie Coffey
What would have happened to the hull?
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 1 June 2023
Willie Coffey
Briefly, with regard to the beggaring of belief issue that was mentioned earlier, the point that the committee—and, perhaps, the public—were making, Mr Miller, is that there is a reasonable expectation that bonuses or incentives would somehow be connected to performance and delivery, rather than to competitiveness and retention of staff. We—and the Government—were genuinely surprised to learn that that system was not connected to performance and delivery. Clearly, the project is five years late and well over budget, so it is difficult for us—and, I am sure, the public—to understand how that situation could continue to be maintained. However, we dwelled on that a moment ago, so I will probably leave it at that, if that is okay, convener and Mr Miller.
I will start with a couple of questions to Mr Tydeman. It is good to see you here again in front of the committee, with a chance to give us your view on how the project has fared since the beginning. In your opening remarks, you outlined that a number of reasons lay behind the delays and cost overruns. You specifically mentioned events in 2015 and 2019, which ultimately meant that timely completion of the vessel was “unrecoverable”. You talked about design and build sequencing and contractual strategies. Since the public are so interested in the project, will you expand a little on what you meant by that and what the issues were that, in your opinion, meant that the project, even at that stage, was unrecoverable?
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 1 June 2023
Willie Coffey
Over many years, the committee has examined a number of projects. I think that it would be reasonable to say that, in our view, if mistakes are made at the outset, usually, there is no successful conclusion at the end, either with regard to time or budget. We have seen a number of examples that fit that category. If the project leaders do not get it right at the beginning, they are hardly likely to get it right at the end. Would you say that that is a fair description of the entire process?
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 1 June 2023
Willie Coffey
To run forward to the present and follow up on questions on costs from my colleague Sharon Dowey, what is the biggest contributory factor to the cost overrun for vessel 802?
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 1 June 2023
Willie Coffey
My question was quite specific. What would have happened to the yard and the jobs, and what would have happened to the 802 hull that is in the yard if we had not completed it?
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 1 June 2023
Willie Coffey
The convener did his level best to glean more detail from everyone on the analysis of the decisions that were reached. Inflation of the cost of materials was mentioned. Has that been a significant issue in the final cost estimate for vessel 802?
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 1 June 2023
Willie Coffey
That covers the second question that I was going to ask about progress on the recommendations.
I will ask a final question of the Scottish Government officials. Mr Irwin, if the cabinet secretary had accepted your conclusion on the value-for-money assessment for 802, what would have been the practical consequences of not completing it? What would have happened to the yard and the jobs? What would have happened to 802 had he accepted your advice?
Local Government, Housing and Planning Committee
Meeting date: 30 May 2023
Willie Coffey
Are there examples of remediation having been done with the agreement of a quorum or some other kind of agreement?
Local Government, Housing and Planning Committee
Meeting date: 30 May 2023
Willie Coffey
You probably heard the earlier discussion about why it took over a year to get an in-principle agreement with some developers. Will you explain why, from the Scottish Government’s point of view, it took a year to get to the point of agreement?