The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 2524 contributions
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 26 February 2025
Stuart McMillan
Yes.
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 26 February 2025
Stuart McMillan
A few years ago, I was at a meeting of one of the local community councils, and there were local authority councillors there, too. When a question came up about this particular proposal, one of the councillors—who is now retired—said, “The trunk road’s not a problem for the council to solve; it’s a problem for the Scottish Government to solve,” rather than taking a holistic approach and thinking, “If this goes ahead, what is the impact going to be on the existing infrastructure?” I would suggest that that exemplifies what Ashleigh Madjitey just said about a lack of leadership.
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 26 February 2025
Stuart McMillan
Sure. Regarding paragraph 92’s first bullet point on equalities, have you had any dialogue with ScotRail about its disability access work?
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 26 February 2025
Stuart McMillan
If someone buys a ticket to use a train, they purchase the ticket, but part of that also covers the cost of accessing the rail, because Network Rail is a separate organisation.
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 26 February 2025
Stuart McMillan
I will ask about a different area in relation to paragraph 16: train travel. When the report was being put together, was any analysis undertaken of the true cost of train journeys and train fares?
Network Rail is still reserved to Westminster. However, the cost to ScotRail of accessing the rail will clearly add to the cost of a ticket. If Network Rail were to be devolved, that could have a positive impact in reducing the cost of tickets.
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 26 February 2025
Stuart McMillan
You reference a cross-Government plan in paragraph 17 of your report. Is that only within Scotland, or is it UK-wide?
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 26 February 2025
Stuart McMillan
I have a range of questions on things that are dotted throughout the report. Before I get into them, I want to follow on from Colin Beattie’s questions about the additional information that is to be sent to the committee. Can that be put alongside the report on the Audit Scotland website to help to provide background?
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 26 February 2025
Stuart McMillan
I genuinely think that paragraph 35 is a cop-out, to be honest. There are some urban authorities that will have rural parts to them, but I accept the point about more solely rural local authority areas. Once again, however, I think of my constituency, and an area that has been suggested for a housing development. It is equidistant between two train stations, and it is just off a trunk road. The only way to get to any of the train stations will be to drive.
Active travel routes can be put in, but in my area, it rains quite a lot, so they will not be used a great deal. The only way to get to somewhere is to get on to a trunk road that is already congested at peak times. Despite folk highlighting concerns, however, the measures are still being progressed.
That is what has been going on from a planning perspective. Councils do not need any additional guidance on planning—they know their area better than any Government of any colour or stripe would do. For me, paragraph 35 of the report really is a cop-out, when I consider what is going on in my patch.
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 26 February 2025
Stuart McMillan
I have a 20-minute neighbourhoods example, but I will not go into it today, because I can talk to you about it another time.
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 26 February 2025
Stuart McMillan
Sure. With regard to paragraph 45 of the report, and the “detailed analysis”, do you have any indication of the cost of the reports involved in that?