The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 1877 contributions
Social Justice and Social Security Committee
Meeting date: 8 January 2026
Claire Baker
Ashley Campbell, do you want to come in?
Social Justice and Social Security Committee
Meeting date: 8 January 2026
Claire Baker
I will leave it there, convener.
Social Justice and Social Security Committee
Meeting date: 8 January 2026
Claire Baker
The previous witnesses also talked about the Scottish Government’s approach to private lets, whether there needs to be more clarity about their importance and whether they are part of the answer to social housing and homelessness pressures. They felt that there was a lack of clarity from the Government about how it sees private rents. Do you agree that there is not a clear message about the expectation on the private sector in relation to Scotland’s housing issues?
Social Justice and Social Security Committee
Meeting date: 8 January 2026
Claire Baker
My final question concerns the calls for the 30 per cent level to be increased. When it was initially introduced, the level was 50 per cent but it has been at 30 per cent for more than 10 years. In 2024, it was unfrozen and reset at 30 per cent, and, subsequently, it has been frozen again.
There is an argument that, if it were to be increased, there could be unintended consequences. There could be behavioural changes on the part of landlords, who would increase rents. We are looking at introducing rent controls in Scotland and there is a concern that, while we are waiting for those rent controls, there is an opportunity for landlords to increase rents again so that they creep up before we get the controls. What are your thoughts on that?
Social Justice and Social Security Committee
Meeting date: 8 January 2026
Claire Baker
That is great.
Social Justice and Social Security Committee
Meeting date: 8 January 2026
Claire Baker
The City of Edinburgh Council’s written submission talks about the high rents that you are experiencing and the difficulty of bridging that gap. The broad market rental area—BRMA—in Edinburgh is calculated within Lothian, whereas the BRMA in Glasgow is calculated within greater Glasgow. Would you support a review of the boundaries of the geographical areas? That would lead to winners and losers, so is that the way to resolve the issue? Rents in Edinburgh are being compared with rents in Midlothian and other areas.
Social Justice and Social Security Committee
Meeting date: 8 January 2026
Claire Baker
It is about temporary accommodation. Les Robertson said that the situation is “patently unfair”. This might not be correct, but I think that 90 per cent of the cost is paid by the DWP and local authorities pick up the rest. I am sorry—I have been trying to find the figure in my papers.
However, surely the problem is that we have increased the number of people living in temporary accommodation. For example, we now have 10,000 children in such accommodation. We have seen a spike in the number, which is due to a shortage of housing to move them to. It is the housing crisis that is creating the bulk of the temporary accommodation issue, because we cannot move people into other properties.
We heard from the previous panel that people are reluctant to move to the private sector, because they feel that there is a lack of security. They are waiting for social housing, but we are not building enough social houses to enable us to move people out of temporary accommodation. That is why local authorities are having to carry the burden of people in temporary accommodation.
Social Justice and Social Security Committee
Meeting date: 8 January 2026
Claire Baker
I just want to clarify what I said earlier. As I said, the maximum subsidy that councils can receive is set at 90 per cent of LHA rates, but the rates that are used are those from 2011, as Sheila Haig said, and average rents have increased by 60 per cent since then. I recognise that councils are carrying the rising cost of temporary accommodation.
Social Justice and Social Security Committee
Meeting date: 8 January 2026
Claire Baker
Could efficiencies be made within the current system that would free up some resources?
Social Justice and Social Security Committee
Meeting date: 8 January 2026
Claire Baker
I have a couple of points on which I seek clarification. The Crisis paper, which is helpful, says:
“42% of Scottish households face a gap between their LHA and actual rent”.
Can you confirm that figure?