The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 861 contributions
Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Meeting date: 25 September 2025
Keith Brown
Thank you.
Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Meeting date: 25 September 2025
Keith Brown
This is about the budget.
Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Meeting date: 25 September 2025
Keith Brown
Yes—I will come on to question 2 when you have answered that one.
Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Meeting date: 25 September 2025
Keith Brown
It is good to hear that.
I have a relatively quick question, which goes back to the visitor levy. You said that you would like the money to be ring fenced. I agree that, where it is raised, proceeds from the levy should be directed towards cultural assets and cultural activities, at least in part, but who are you asking to do that ring fencing? Is it the local authority, which would raise it, or do you want the Scottish Government to give local authorities some kind of prod?
Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Meeting date: 25 September 2025
Keith Brown
Yes—I mean the whole budget process.
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 24 September 2025
Keith Brown
You gave an example about singling out a candidate for being non-meritorious. Nobody wants to get into that situation. It is not good for the candidate, either.
I have a separate point on NHS appointments specifically. You might not want to answer this question, and I would understand why if you did not. Is the proliferation of NHS boards part of the reason that we struggle to fill all of them with the right calibre of candidates all the time?
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 24 September 2025
Keith Brown
It would be really useful to compare neighbouring countries. That should be more than what you are able to say about the links that you have with elsewhere. There is a need to look at performance and at the issues that are faced, not just in this area of appointments. That seems to be an obvious piece of work that would be useful.
Also, I agree that we are often the last to see the merits of the things that we do here in Scotland. We tend to concentrate on the problems.
My last question is about what you have been saying about incivility. That is a huge issue. We had a situation last week in Parliament where the refusal to accept an amendment to a justice bill has resulted in a number of members being accused on social media of favouring child rape. That is how bad it is getting here now. Many members have cameras and police patrols around our houses these days because we have received death threats and so on.
I agree with you that incivility is a present problem, and I was interested in the work that you are doing with others in that regard. It is important that you speak up publicly about it. That would not be to say whatever I want you to say but to say what you found. I have a view that perhaps part of the reason that people do not come forward—I think that you alluded to this—is that they have seen how people in public roles can be treated. Unless people and trusted actors like you also speak up about the situation and not just those who are affected by it directly, such as members of boards, Parliaments and councils, it will be hard to turn the tide.
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 24 September 2025
Keith Brown
I did not really expect that, but there you go.
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 24 September 2025
Keith Brown
In what you have talked about, you have referred a couple of times already to accountability. If the public watch First Minister’s question time every week—I am sure that you will have to do that as well, whether you want to or not—all that they will see is questions being put to the First Minister, quite legitimately, about issues in the health service. Where do you think they see the accountability of 22 different health boards? Do they see that at all, or do they see it as the Government being responsible?
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 24 September 2025
Keith Brown
It is just that, in my experience, if somebody has an issue with a health board or with health services in their area, the last people they go to will be the health board. They might access the complaint system, or they might go to councillors or MSPs, but the health board does not feature. Unless it is something like the closure of a hospital, the health board does not feature at all. That is my point. Is the health board a needless layer? I suppose that it is difficult for you to comment on this, because it is down to Government policy, but does the current configuration of 22 health boards, a number of which the public do not even know exist, add to accountability in any way?