The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 2063 contributions
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 11 March 2025
Michelle Thomson
Thank you.
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 11 March 2025
Michelle Thomson
You have given a lot of information so far. In reading through the financial memorandum, I was struck by the number of detailed points that outline the basis on which and the provisions by which the estimates were arrived at. That suggested to me that a lot of careful thought had been given to the matter. It also suggested to me, given that there are 95 clarifying points, that confidence in the figure of £198 million must be relatively low, with good reason and with every justification.
This is a question that I often ask at this committee: how confident are you and your supporting official in that figure, on a scale of zero to 10, where zero is no confidence and 10 is 100 per cent confidence? With 95 clarifying points, I think that the only thing of which we can be certain is that £198 million is not accurate.
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 11 March 2025
Michelle Thomson
The question was actually about fiscal sustainability.
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 11 March 2025
Michelle Thomson
What do you think the reason for that is?
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 11 March 2025
Michelle Thomson
I am not asking for an accurate figure on a scale of zero to 10. My question specifically was: how confident are you that the figure of £198 million is accurate?
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 11 March 2025
Michelle Thomson
That is the rub. In the figures that we have pulled out today, we have known unknowns—my colleague Ross Greer brought out some of those—but we also have unknown unknowns, about which none of us has a clue. Plus, there is your point that, if the bill were to be passed and become a success, the figures could be quite startling because of the increased provision that would be required.
This committee, including the Conservative members, is very vexed about fiscal sustainability. How do you think the unknown unknowns and known unknowns would factor into the fiscal sustainability of Scotland’s public finances if the bill were to be passed? What reflection have you given to that?
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 11 March 2025
Michelle Thomson
Okay—I get your point.
Have you done any research—you may well have done, and I have missed it—on other countries that have taken a legislative approach rather than a principled human rights approach, for example? Has any other country done this?
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 11 March 2025
Michelle Thomson
If the bill does not go through as you intend, what is your plan B?
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 4 March 2025
Michelle Thomson
Yes.
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 4 March 2025
Michelle Thomson
I fully accept the necessity of inquiries being independent, but there is a tension between that, their cost and the value that they bring, and it is of principal interest.
Looking at your numbers, my understanding of the article from last September is that some contributory bodies, such as councils and Police Scotland, were unable to articulate their staff costs for supporting inquiries. That might be of interest, too, if we are going to look a little further at the issue. Can you dig out what you have on that? Particularly with the Eljamel inquiry starting and the fact that others are still running, it might be useful to start collecting those costs as we move forward with this.